Site Map

Home

About COPD

 

What Is It?/Who Develops It?

 

Should I See A Dr? (A Checklist)

 

Women & COPD

 

COPD - Latest  Web Info & Research (links)

 

Talking To Your Dr

 

Before You Go

 

Initial Visit Q's

 

Follow Up Visit Q's

 

What is a COPD Action Plan? NEW

 

COPD Action Plan Link

Ask the RRT

 

 

Ask The Respiratory Therapist YOUR Question

 

Recent RRT Q&A's

 

Archived Q&A's (2008/09)

 

Archived Q's & A's (2010)

 

Archived Q & A's 2011

 

Medicines

 

 

The Different "Types"

 

Know Your Meds - A Reference Guide for Canadians

 

(pdf version)

 

Drug Names/Equivalents in Different Countries

 

Medical Acronyms

Are You Newly Diagnosed?

 

 

If Nothing Else, Read This

 

Just Between Us - From Your Fellow COPDer's

Breathing

 

Breathing Distress

 

Anxiety & Pursed Lip Breathing (PLB) (Part 1)

 

NEWPursed Lip Breathing   (Part 2)

 

Diagphagmatic Breathing

 

Exhale & Relax

Breathing Tests

(Understanding Them)

 

 

PFT (Pulmonary Function Test)

 

Spirometry Tests

 

Pulmonary Function 101 (Understanding How Your Lungs Work)

Finger Pulse Oximeters

 

About Them, Why Own One & Where to Obtain One

Exercise

 

 

Why It's Important

 

FREE Exercise DVD

Nutrition

 

 

Why It's Important

 

Nutritional Needs & Foods To Avoid

For COPD Caregivers & Support People

 

 

Dear family

 

Sick Lungs Don't Show

Lung Transplant

 

 

Lung Transplant Ctrs in Canada

 

Meet Melody (pre transplant ) The Waiting

 

Post Transplant Q's &A's of Melody

 

Follow a Couple of Tx Patients on Their Journey

HOME

 

Recent COPD Questions for the RRT

 

Mark Mangus, Sr. BSRC, RRT, RPFT, FAARC

 

Note: The weekly cut-off day is Wednesday evening. If your questions are received "after" that day, they will appear in the following week's postings. Questions and answers are usually uploaded to this site by Sunday evening.

 

Previous Questions & Answers  (2010) & (2011) of Mark Mangus, BSRC, RRT, RPFT, FAARC

archived by topic, alphabetically

 

Previous Questions and answers 

of RRT Tracy Cushing, covering 2008 and 2009, have been archived by topic alphabetically. 

 

Disclaimer:  The responses supplied by Mr. Mangus to your question is intended solely as  "general information"  only and  NOT  diagnostic in any fashion.  Mr. Mangus's  answers are based on his understanding of your query and on his personal knowledge and training.   As with anything of a medical nature you should ALWAYS check with your physician. 

Current Questions & Answers

May 13th, 2012

Unknown Reason for Breathing Problems (Possible Allergens) Also  Cholesterol Discussion

Hi Mark,  NO copd, hopefully. Smoked in my youth, quit at age 24.  now 59. haven't been seriously sick in years 20 or so, except occasional lethargic sensations. approx three years ago. started taking cholesterol meds. pravistation, cholesterol in the 350's in spite of many years of exercise and good diet.
starting suddenly in august of last year 2011, I awoke to what I thought was pneumonia. I had just started a new job one week , data entry info from old files.  There were no other symptoms. no nasal congestion, I did seem to have a flavor of medal in my throat for weeks. Once seeing a doctor. The did chest x-rays. that came up with some bronchitis. He gave me antibiotics. it slowly cleared. Now I have no decent medical to be sure. That doctor is no longer there and I see a nurse practioner.  I had taken antibiotics off and on for about three months.
They insist it is allergies, but I get a bad episode almost every three months. Terrible hacking and coughing. Lungs sound scary. congested.  I will have quiet spells, and then all of a sudden coughing.
I've been taking the equivalent of Claritin for three months, that seems to help, but I got hit will a spell again, and when it happens, it also drains me, It really feels like a serious cold.  but there is no nasal congestion. since the claritin no  post nasal drip and itcy eyes.

any suggestions. 

ps the metallic taste cleared after the second round of antibiotics. 


Laura

Hi Laura,

It's tough to guess what may be going on, though, if they think it's allergies, I wonder if you have had a work-up for that - skin tests, etc?  How about a PFT (pulmonary functions test)?  Spirometry, pre- and post-bronchodilator might show airway reactivity - the symptom most commonly manifested with allergies.  Chronic bronchitis could be another possibility.

I'm intrigued that you began having symptoms after starting your new job.  You spoke of "old files" and data transfer as your function.  Are the records 'musty' or been in storage for long?  Could you be reacting to something in the paper they're composed of?

How's your cholesterol 'now' with the prevastatin?  Is it normalized?  How about your triglycerides?  I ask because I had a severe problem with elevated cholesterol and triglycerides that I was able to normalize without using statins.  For more than three years, now, I have taken high-dose Niacin (3000mg/day) - (had to work my way up to my current maintenance dose from very low dose over a period of months) plus higher-dose flax seed oil (3000mg/day).  But, I dropped my cholesterol from almost 300 to about 110 and my triglycerides from almost 500 to the 90's on both AND my high-density lipoproteins (HDL) are almost double what they were when I started my regimen (in the 50's). 

Many statin preparations contain low-dose niacin.  But, it is not always enough.  AND, because of the discomfort of flushing, many folks abandon it quickly, rather than tough it out 'til it no longer occurs.  (Flush-free Niacin is not nearly as effective as regular, sustained/prolonged release is).  I didn't want to take statins because of the side effects that are so common with them - if I could avoid having to take them.  And I'm so pleased with what my regimen has done for me and continues to do.

If you can give me more to go on, I might have some suggestions for directions to point you in for further investigation and possibly even a possible reason for your troubles.

Best Wishes,

Mark

Pulmonary Fibrosis

I have Lung Fibrosis I was diagnosed aboutt 10 yrs ago. now getting worse, I am on oxygen 24 - 7. The doctors I see do not seem to help me at all, just waiting for the day I stop breathing.
I would like a second opinion on this condition. And even trying for a lung transplant if possible.
OR they are interested in other findings like Pulmonary Blood Pressure.

Marjorie

Hi Marjorie,

I'm sorry to learn of your troubles.  Pulmonary Fibrosis is a nasty problem for which we still have a paucity of tools to combat/treat.  Pulmonary Hypertension is a condition that develops as pulm. fibrosis develops and advances.  It is due to the accompanying hypoxia as it affects the heart, over time.

Unfortunately, today, the most effective treatment to resolve pulm fibrosis is lung transplant.  So, I think you're thinking correctly in your surmising that it may be worth pursuing.  The sooner you find out if you're a candidate, the better, even if it will end up being some time before you actually need to undergo the procedure.

Best Wishes,

Mark

May 6th, 2012

Meds Sequence and Wheezing

Hi;  just returning my question.l take symbicort twice a day 2puffs each time plus half tab. unihyl,spirva once. Wheezing still there. What l was asking they should put something in the meds that we could taste and then we would know we are getting the dose. Do you agree?l was shown how to take them but l still have breathing problems and wheezing. Ventolin helps for a bit. My test showed l have 38 percent lung function. Oxygen on finger test is at 92-94.ventolin l take 2 puffs 4 times a day.  TY for your time.

Doug

Hi Doug,

If your saturation "at rest" is running only 92 - 94 %, it is reasonably easy to predict that when you get up and move, it is dropping below 88 % and doing so fairly quickly.  If you haven't had a 6 minute walk test, you should seek to have one done.  You likely need oxygen for mobility and potentially, also for sleep. 

If you are taking Ventolin that many times a day, you could be taking your meds in a order that thwarts the effects of the bronchodilator medicine in the Symbicort.  Be sure you are taking the Symbicort BEFORE you take an Ventolin, in the morning.  Then wait at least 30 minutes before taking any Ventolin - IF you still need help.  When the evening dose of Symbicort is due, be sure that you have NOT taken any Ventolin within the previous two hours.  Ventolin binds to the same receptor sites within the lungs as does the Ventolin.  If the Ventolin is taken too soon before Symbicort, the receptors cannot bind to it and it is shed from your body before having exerted any beneficial action.

The spiriva should be taken within a few minutes after taking your morning Symbicort.  I'm left wondering what your "post-bronchodilator" FEV-1 changes to on your PFT's.  If a pre and post FEV-1 measurement hasn't been done, then, again, you should ask for at least one to be done - especially in view of the fact that you have wheezing. 

There could be other things going on with your lungs.  But, these are some obvious starting points for you to consider acting on.

Best Wishes,

Mark

COPD or a Bad Cold

I think I have a bad cold. I was sent for a chest x ray my doc thinks I have mild Copd oxygen output was 94% on azythromycin. What do you think?  Nose is stuffy phlegm is clear

John

Hi John,

You could be right.  Be sure to have your saturation checked after you recover from your bug to be sure that it returns to normal.  Ask for a 6 minute walk test to be sure you are not dropping your oxygen during exertion.

Best Wishes,

Mark

 

April 29, 2012

Nebulizing Meds

Can I use Glutathione with a nebulizer and also use Symbicort?  The Glutathione is from a pharmacy in southern California. Each is to be taken twice a day.

Maureen

Hi Maureen,

First let me be sure I understand what you're asking.  You are asking about taking the two medications at the same time and concerned about any interaction between them, correct?  You are NOT asking if it's OK to "nebulize" BOTH drugs, either separately or mixed together, correct?  Symbicort is not suitable for nebulization, if that's what you were asking about.  It must always be taken from its designated inhaler.

Those points settled, you CAN take both medications without concern.  They are completely different and do different things.  One will not interfere with the other.  And taking both is not going to put you at any risk of harm. 

Best Wishes,

Mark

Oxygen Desaturation..... Dangerous When?

Hi Mark
Just a fast question for you.

My question is. At what 02 saturation level does the number registered become dangerous to one,s health??

I have looked up many articles on this very subject, and no one has the same consensus.
One article said. Any number below 92. Others said 90 is the cut off , and then others swear by 88 or below.
Why Mark is there not a more world wide definitive number, and why does nobody agree .
The answers in regards to the number seem to be all over the map.

Just to give you mark an idea.
In my province of Ontario, the government will NOT pay for supplemental 02 unless your numbers are consistently below 88. 
Other countries have another number that they use.
Why Mark can they not agree on a Universal number??

Thanks mark and the best to you and your family. Philip

Hi Philip,

Needless to say, this is a carry-over question from the same issue discussed extensively over the last week on the EFFORTS list.  So, I feel a bit "baited", here.

The reason you will find no agreement or a definitive number as you lament not being able to find is because there simply IS NO SUCH NUMBER . . . at least not with the conditions you and others are bent on applying.  It is simply NOT black and white!  It is different for everyone and dependent upon many subtle factors of their own condition. 

As I explained the other day in a post on EFFORTS, the 88 % comes from the NOTT and BMS studies where it was selected as an arbitrary low point for purposes of delineating populations in the study groups and ascertaining survival with and without using supplemental oxygen and for how much of the time they used it. 

Again, I explained that even the 88 % or 85 % opined by many in yet other countries - or the 80 % set in one province of Canada as the lowest acceptable saturation without trying to correct it with supplemental oxygen is relative. 

Consider the inhabitants of the Andes or the Himalayas.  They live NORMAL lives with saturations in the low 80's and aren't considered "hypoxic" until their saturation drops into the 70's.  When we fly, our saturation drops to 87 % (I just measured mine during several flights to Las Vegas and San Francisco two weeks ago) and , while we may feel a bit tired and have less than stellar energy, we are fine for those short periods of time.  I'm certainly not going to suffer and organ damage because of those several flights.  And flight attendants and pilots and their crews withstand drops into the mid 80's daily as they fly for their livelihood. 

The fact is that what is "damaging" to a person is the long-term, repetitive drops in saturation in the face of having clinically significant lung disease and a vulnerable cardiac condition as a combination of influences.  And it is not that their saturation drops to or below some magic number, because it drops to different lows at different times under different circumstances and influences of the moment. 

The answer to your "damage" question lies in the example that may be likened to a boxer who takes many punches to many places of different kinds and strengths and who after enduring so many over the course of several boxing rounds finally takes a final fall and passes out because he can't take any more punches.  Now, you ask me: "Which punch was it that did him in?"  I don't know.  The last one is the one after which he fell.  But, it took the cumulative effect of all the previous punches to lead to the culmination in that last punch.

And so it is with desaturation.  While you and so many others are trying to put conditions and numbers into a tidy and neat box, the contents of the box are like a glob of Jell-O that doesn't want to fit into the box and is too difficult to handle to tame and control it. 

So, the best I can do is to reiterate what you will repeatedly find when you do find the information in the literature, 85 to 88 % seems to be the most evidence-based range of lows below which long-term, repeated drops to and below will eventually result in permanent changes for the worse in cardiac function and pulmonary blood pressure increases.  That's the best we can say and do.  If it's not enough, I have to say: "I'm sorry!" 

Still, the 'general' recommendations we have to go by is to do your best to keep your saturation above 88 % as much of the time as is possible.  90 % or greater is the recommended 'minimum' target for 'sure' safety with higher saturations targeted for increased comfort.

Best Regards,

Mark

Frequency of Ventolin Use

l use ventolin like lm told and more when l walk is this ok? Should they put something in symbicort and spiriva so we are getting the dose?  TY

Doug

Hi Doug,

I'm afraid I don't quit understand what it is that you're asking.  If you are taking Symbicort and Spiriva, then you should need ventolin ONLY in-between the Symbicrot doses and ONLY on an as needed basis.

You say you use your ventolin as you're told".  But, you don't say how often you've been told to take it OR under what conditions you're supposed to take it.  And, you say you take more when you walk.  So, it sounds to me like you're not taking your Symbicort (and possibly also your Ventolin) properly, since it seems to require more than is usually needed for normal doses under usual conditions.  Can you write back and tell me by what pattern you take your inhaled medications - times and which ones when?

Best Regards,

Mark

Treadmill Walking vs Outdoor Walking

Mark,

Your explanation to Norma recently re difference between walking outdoors and treadmill is a good review.  But I have a slightly different question.  What value is it to only use a treadmill in PR when life requires many different grades?  Decisions for supplemental O2 based on a treadmill seems inadequate - I understand about adding grades, but wouldn't that take many weeks to equal walking outside?   I too experience the difference.  With warmer Spring weather I have been walking outdoors rather than use my treadmill (45in at 2.5., lowest sat 92)  While I don't find any significant change in my breathing outdoors and it does have several long and short increases in grade. I have been tracking my starting HR, O2 sat, periodically during my walk, and when I finish.  I've slowly increased my time and distance (now 38-40 min, 1.5-1.8 miles.)  My heart rate has decreased from106 to now 92-96.  Good, right?  Originally my lowest SaO2 was 91, but now it is 85-86 and lasting much longer during my walk.  It comes up to 90 when I finish and then back up to 96 over 3-4 minutes.  I would much rather walk outdoors as that is real life  So I guess my question is just how realistic is treadmill work in PH compare with real life activities?  How would criteria for O2 in RH match outdoor work?  Or am I splitting hairs?

Doris

Hi Doris,

You're not splitting hairs. But, some of what you tell me causes me concern.

First, when one works out in the gym, they chose things like the treadmill, cycles and eliptical/step gliders, etc AND they generally work out quite differently from how folks tend to work out in PR.  While I've said that walking on the level treadmill doesn't exactly match the work of moving your body from point "a" to point "b" when walking outside, that doesn't mean that you can't achieve comparability. 

You note that your hear rate has dropped from 106 to 92 - 93.  But, you don't say if that is resting heart rate or during walking.  But, to be clear, the objective of exercise is to raise your heart rate - 120 - even higher, if your symptoms will permit AND if you can maintain an adequate oxygen saturation while exercising at that higher heart rate.  So, whatever mode and method of exercise you choose should have those objectives.  So, the real question is not the value of treadmill versus walking outdoors on natural terrain.  But, it is the 'manner' in which you walk, which ever means you choose.

Now with regard to saturation, it is NOT desirable to sustain your saturation at the 85 - 86 % you observe yours to be when walking outside.  If you have supplemental oxygen available to use and are prescribed to use it, then you should use it.  You should target keeping your saturation at or above 90 % during walking - whether it be indoors on a treadmill or outdoors on the natural terrain.  That it comes up to 96 % when you stop (after 3 - 4 minutes) does not make sustaining 85 - 86 % during walking any healthier for you.  Recovery time, contrary to what some will say, has NO bearing upon the adverse effect of sustaining saturations that are below an acceptable level of 88 % during exercise.

So, my recommendation for you would be to exercise as vigorously as you can to raise your heart rate AND sustain an adequate saturation so as not to put yourself at risk for organ function compromise (mainly, your heart) in the long run.

Best Wishes,

Mark

COPD & HOCM

I have recently been diagnosed with COPD.  I also have HOCM and I'm wondering how they will affect each other.

Diane

Hi Diane

That is something I can't begin to speculate on.  Your cardiologist and pulmonologist have infinitely better means to answer that question for you than I or anyone else could.  I suspect that they will likely tell you that only time will tell.  But, certainly, put your questions and concerns to them both!

Best Wishes,

Mark

April 22nd, 2012

Oxygen Level Query

Hi Mark, my daughter suffers with FA ,she was taken to hospital a few days ago where they found her blood pressure was low and her oxygen was at 8% ,and said she could have slipped into a coma, I am so worried that this may happen again now and we won’t b able to tell ,please help me understand this ,thanks Julie

Julie

Hi Julie,

I'm afraid you haven't provided enough information for me to help you at this time.  As well, your relating of your daughter's oxygen level is not correct.  No one can have an oxygen level of "8 %" and be alive, in any of the possible ways "8 %" could represent.  I am not familiar with an abbreviation for a diagnosis of "FA".  please spell out her diagnosis completely so that I will not misunderstand what it is she suffers from.  If you can write back with the correct and more complete information I will be happy to try to provide some answers for you. 

Best Wishes,

Mark

Prednisone

How bad is prednisone for flare ups of copd....my doc tries to keep me away from them but yet that’s what opens me up to breath better....I’m already on all the inhalers and a nebulizer


Allan

Hi Allan,

Prednisone is the drug we "love to hate".  It DOES work very well to subdue symptoms and make the user feel better.  But, it is a mixed blessing, as it suppresses your immunity, making you more susceptible to infection AND playing havoc with calcium distribution and use in the body, leading to susceptibility to loss of bone density and osteoporosis, if used too much for too long.  And, how much is too much or too long is different for every individual, making determination of what is safe for a given individual very difficult to ascertain.  That is why your doctor is hesitant to prescribe it very often.

The trick is in being able to tolerate the symptoms that cannot be changed and to counter them with activity and exercise as well as good diet and life style/habits (like refraining from smoking, etc.)  Pulmonary rehabilitation is of great help in learning to overcome and tolerate difficult breathing.  Taking medications in the proper amount and sequence is another key to living well. If you are using your nebulizer with short-acting medications and then following it with long-acting versions, you are working against yourself to achieve effectiveness of the long-acting medications.  AND you could be taking much more medication than you really need to because of the ineffective sequencing of your medications.  So, simply being on all possible medications alone PLUS a nebulizer may not be as effective in reducing your symptoms/breathing difficulties as you might think.  If you can tell me more, especially what medications you are taking and in what order/sequence/timing/interval you are taking them, I might be able to glean more of from what your difficulties may arise

Best Wishes,

Mark

Good PFT  Numbers, But Having Problems With Breathlessness

Dear Mark,

We exchanged emails back in 2004 when I started out on this road. Regrettably I'm still on the same page but living with this the best I can, myself and my wife have had a number of children since we last spoke.

To recap I had asthma as a child and smoked for 17 years foolishly taking steroid inhalers to counter act the effects of the cigarettes. I gave up in 2004 at 34  after a bad chest infection and a constant sensation of not being able to get a deep breath. After 8 years I still cannot get those elusive deep breaths and this has a constant effect on my life. I also have some phlegm most days and a cough. My breathing bothers me.

I had more PFT's in 2009 (values unchanged) and I also own a handheld spirometer and I have some insight. My pulmos verdict is that I have twitchy airways and he puts the uncomfortable breathing down to anxiety. His Verdict; I may have some small airway re modeling which should not cause the symptoms I experience.

I have an FEV1 at 4.25 and an FVC of 5.82 (I'm M, 42yo and 181 cm) so my numbers are good. Diffusion is normal and I have no reversibility.

I have started biking to lose weight (14st) and can do 50mls in 2 hrs. After I bike my breathing is not right for two days at least, I cannot get a deep breath which drives me nuts, although I can exercise well.

I have three questions for you..

1. Where to now with this, is this as good as it gets?
2. Should I use a short or long acting bronchodilator for what seems to be Exercise Induced Asthma.
3. What do you think of my FE1 / FVC ratio in light of my symptoms. I see Crapo and others say this value should be over 80%.

Lastly have you ever seen anyone with normal FEV1 & FVC and a history of Asthma / Smoking complain such as this.

Thanks for your time,

Con.

Hi Con,

With your pulmonary functions as good as they are and your FEV-1/FVC ratio still within normal limits (at > 70 %), you have extremely minimal obstruction and none that could possibly be considered clinically significant.

The complain of not being able to take in a deep breath is relative and very subjective.  You obviously can indeed take in plenty of deep breath with your FVC at 5.82 L!  So your 'sensation' is a mis-fire in your brain.  What causes folks who have clinically significant COPD to develop the sensation that they cannot get enough air in - a.k.a. a deep enough breath - is the fact that they are trapping so much air that they have no room for 'additional' air to be taken in.  Their quest is to use pursed-lips breathing to help "EXHALE" more effectively so that on subsequent breaths, there will be enough room for MORE fresh air to come in.  They need to 'make space' to accommodate a bigger breath. 

That is not your problem at all.  In fact, there simply is no good reason for your sensation and therefore, no reasonable way to explain it aside from the possibility of some amount of airway remodeling resulting from the combined smoking and steroid inhaler use.  Still, your changes are simply not enough to explain your breathlessness/complaint of not being able to take in a bigger breath.

Inhalers will NOT do anything for you and should not even be a consideration.  Try exhaling more deliberately and using pursed lips breathing to see if you notice any difference or improvement.

Best wishes,

Mark

Smoking, Industrial Exposures & COPD

Mark;  I am questioning the band wagon approach to the medical and worker comp boards insistence that COPD is only caused from cigarette smoking.
I was exposed to Asbestos and Silica dust in my 20's with the added fun of being involved in a natural gas fire/explosion at the same establishment.
All of this was not enough.  The fire sealed up my nose,damaged my sinus and left lung.  Further after trying to keep working I was involved in a business that used Industrial Chemicals to strip furniture which lead ( no pun intended) to Peripheral Neuropathy (toxic). Our neuropathy group has noted over 100 neuropathic health problems.
My  question is with all of this happening what are the chances that my COPD is more related to Industrial exposures than having been (20 yrs without)
a Cigarette Buffer not a heavy smoker.
I thank you for your time and will be interested in hearing your reply.
Best Regards, R

Hi "R",

COPD can indeed be caused by inhalation of asbestos and silica.  Thermal injury to one's airways can result in a combined defect of restrictive AND obstructive lung disease. smoking history up to about 20 years for many is not enough history to presume as a primary cause of COPD when one is younger.  You did not indicate how long you smoked, only that you've been quit for 20 years.  Lastly, inhalation of the kinds of agents used in furniture restoration can cause either or both restrictive and/or obstructive lung diseases

Unfortunately, with your history of several incidents that can cause COPD and a smoking history, it is virtually impossible to separate each factor to ascertain if and how much each might contribute to your COPD.  Asbestos inhalation is dose-dependent, so requires significant and dense exposure for a short duration effect and moderate long-term exposure for a sustained effect.  Silica is the same.   Your inhalation injury from the fire should have been well-documented in order to determine what permanent damage was caused by it.  Regular follow-up with x-rays/CT scans and especially, PFT;s would be necessary to gather that kind of evidence. 

So, if, on the surface your smoking history seems to be significant (> 20 pack-years - 1 pack/day X 20 years) then it is impossible to tease out the other influences.

In any case, with your multiple exposure history and smoking on top of it, no one can reasonably or reasonably accurately estimate how much of your lung disease, if any was cause by what.  Insofar as any neuropathy, only well-performed and sensitive tests of muscles and nerves could possibly detect any such affect on your condition and symptoms.

I'm sorry to be unable to give you more specific information or answers.  But, it's just not possible, based upon your history and from where I sit.

Best Wishes,

Mark

Pulmonary Rehab Needed?

Mark,
I appreciate your answers.
I am 51 and was diagnosed a few years back with severe emphysema/copd. My pulmonary dr. told me I'm at 37 or 38%. I work full-time as a probation officer. I quit smoking 3 years ago and in the last year have become more active. I've been walking, doing recumbent bike and since Aug. 2011 have done 2-3  1 hr. sessions of yoga per week with a personal trainer. This has helped me tremendously gain strength, confidence, energy and my breathing.

My yoga teacher is aware of my COPD and  has read up on poses good for the lungs. She now wants me to do planks to strength my core and abs. I can get in the position and hold it fine. However, because of the straight position (similar to a pushup) I can't get in a full-inhale because of the position of my diaphragm.
Is this okay to do with my lung disease? I am a little anxious doing it because it restricts my breathing, but if it will get better with practice I'm willing to do it. What do you think?

Also, my pulmonary dr. doesn't have the best bedside manner. I asked him about doing pulmonary rehab (at least the exercise part with the respiratory and physical therapists.) He told me pulmonary rehab was for those who couldn't exercise on their own and I was capable of doing this on my own. I'm thinking the extra support and expertise would be helpful!

Thanks for your input.

Moe

Hi Moe,

First you are to be commended for exercising on your own.  In my opinion, one can do most anything they wish - including the strenuous yoga positions - as you describe.  Yes, breathing is restricted by the position.  BUT, it presents an ideal opportunity to learn to control your breathing more with your 'abdomen' while in that position, despite the restriction.  So, I would encourage you to continue.

Since you are indeed exercising well on your own, it is hard to justify the expense of pulmonary rehabilitation, especially since you are able to be so vigorous as your condition currently allows.   So, save the pulmonary rehabilitation for a future time when you may find you can no longer effectively control your symptoms and are less able to exercise so vigorously.

The Internet and forums like copd-Canada provide ample opportunity to continue to learn more about your disease and how to live well with it.  So, there is plenty of "expertise" to be gleaned through your own efforts and searches.

Keep up the good work!

Best Wishes,

Mark

Treadmill Walking vs Land Walking

Why is it that I can walk on a treadmill with no problems, but when I walk off the treadmill, e.g. outside or even in a mall, we become short of breath..nobody seems able to answer this question. It's not just me...I have spoken to others in my BreathWorks program and they have the same problem.

thanks

Norma

Hi Norma,

Yours is a common complaint that seems to be related to the fact that on a treadmill, with the belt coming to meet your feet, you don't do as much work at a given speed as you do when you move the mass of your body from 'point A' to 'point B' as when walking on land.  Add to that terrain variations and the fact that you're also not able to "hang on" to rails, as on a treadmill and you have significantly more work when free-walking than when walking on a treadmill.  If you were to add grade to the treadmill, you would see an increase in your work to breathe that compares to free-walking on land.  I'm not recommending adding grade.  Indeed, if you add anything. add speed until you reach your maximum comfortable walking speed (somewhere over 3 mph)  Then add grade or interval increases and decreases in speed with an 'easy trot' when moving faster - all this ONLY if possible and tolerable.

Just remember to make yourself breathe HARD when you walk on the treadmill so that it will better translate to  similar work when free-walking on land.

Best regards, Mark

April 8th, 2012

PFT Info Review

Hi, I have been recently diagnosed with COPD as a "former cigarette smoker with wheeze" and am trying to better understand my PFT numbers, specifically
       
                           Pre Bronch                                                                   Post Bronch   
                           Pred   LLN       Actual   %Pred                                Actual     %Pred   %Chng

FVC (L)               3.32   2.64       1.86       56                                      2.04         61        +9
FEV1 (L)             2.60   2.04       0.98        37                                     1.22         46        +24
fev1/fvc(%)           79      69          53          66                                      60           75        +13

Lung Vol.
TLC (pleth) (L)    4.90  3.82        5.06     103
RV  (pleth) (L)     1.83  1.07        3.13     171
RV/TLC (Pleth) (%) 37  26           62       167

I am a 54 yr old caucasian female, 84kgs, 160 cm.,  with a history of smoking about 15 cigs/day for approx 32 years. I quit 5 years ago. I had bronchitis at Christmas that just wouldn't go away and was given antibiotics, but my breathing difficulties continued. I am currently using Advair 250 and Spiriva which seems to help.(I don't know what would happen if I stopped using them)
I have been told the deficit is severe, but I feel fine and have never had any problems until I had bronchitis. Could the test be incorrect and the results be skewed because of the bronchitis? When I calculate the numbers as a percentage of LLN rather than pred I get a slightly different story. Do you need more info?
Thank you for your help.

Laura

Hi Laura,

Your PFT shows significant airflow limitation AND evidence of increased "resting lung volumes" indicating fairly significant COPD.   As well, you also have a clinically significant response to bronchodilators (an 'asthma' component.  So, I would say that you indeed NEED to continue the Advair and Spiriva, as they are exerting a significantly beneficial effect. 

I doubt that the results are erroneous, as such limitations as demonstrated on your PFT, while certainly subject to the potential to reflect acute illness, when present, are not going to change all that significantly from your baseline.

That said, that you don't 'feel' all that limited is a GOOD thing!  Being able to function - especially from a physical point of view - without significantly limiting breathing difficulties is your best news AND a factor with which you should be able to improve your breathing and function by adopting a regimen of exercise that will serve to keep you enjoying minimal functional limitations for some time to come. 

So, get out and exercise like mad and make yourself breathe HARD while doing it.  Remember, working hard to breathe, though uncomfortable, will NOT harm you!  It will serve you well to desensitize yourself to what lies ahead in the coming years.

Your FEV-1 of 46 % while significantly reduced, is not low enough to produce significant symptoms during mild exertion.  If you try to run a marathon, you will certainly feel the effects, though.  Still, as others with similar airflow limitation have found, even running a marathon is not a possibility that is out of the question.  I always remind folks that one with "normal" lung function who undergoes removal of one of their lungs is physically reduced to 50 % of their capacities as measured on a PFT.  Yet, folks with one lung DO run marathons - though with having to do much more work to breathe while doing so.  So, again, the bottom line is, you have plenty of lung capacity with which to work.  Don't be afraid to use it!

Best Wishes,

Mark

COPD & HOPE

Hi Mark,

One of the things that I hold on to is some of the good news that comes by us regarding all the strides they are making to cure or stop the progression of this disease. You can exercise all you want, you can run in a marathon, you can go beyond the call of duty with your exercising and doing absolutely everything
right to fight this disease, but without this element to keep us motivated all will be for not.
The element is " HOPE ". WE are all done without it.

I think there should be more discussion and information about what they are working on around the world to help this disease.
As an example.
University of Pittsburgh Announces that COPD is an auto-immune disease.
Stem cells show great promise in rejuvenating lungs with COPD
60 Minutes shows lungs, heart, ears nose being grown in a lab.
People now living far longer than before when receiving a double lung transplant.
Now available non invasive lung reduction surgery.
This Mark is just the tip of the iceberg.
Without HOPE we really have nothing. Hope is what sustains us even through our exercise, because we know if we can last a bit longer, there will be something to come on the scene to help us.
So when you answer Mark someone who is scared that COPD is a death sentence, you have always answered correctly by saying it is a progressive disease
with no known cure at this time. Just do not leave out the " HOPE "

Hope ( no pun intended ) all finds you and your family well

Regards Philip

Hi Philip,

I couldn't have said it all any better than you did.  Hope MUST be an ingredient and an inspiring force in the life and mind of anyone with COPD - - - and many other chronic diseases, as wel, for that matter - - - if they are to survive and thrive in the face of the difficulties attendant with having those diseases.

As well, we can't forget "purpose", which goes hand in hand with hope.  If you haven't got a purpose for getting out of bed each morning and living life toward a positive end, then you are doomed, as well.

While having worked with 'older folks' so much of my career, I can tell you of the warning signs I have come to recognize that bode poorly for folks' survival and thriving.  When one loses their reason for living, hope goes with it.    And even a chronologically young person can meet an earlier demise than would ever be likely.

So, the message for all is to stay engaged/involved with life and living and realize that despite the troubles you may face in living life to the fullest, you have something to contribute to the world and a good reason to trudge on - even in the face of adversity when things get rough

Thanks for reminding us of these important points!

Best Regards,

Mark

Tech Smart Dose Regulator & the Importance of Exercise

Mark,

I cannot thank you enough for your answers.  Yes you are right Houston is a great town for people in my condition, I did not do enough investigation on my own and was not put on oxygen early enough and did not know about physical rehab until I ask for it four years ago.  Like everything in life you need to be your own best advocate.

The regulator that looks the best to me is Tech Smart Dose because I am a very active person who forgets to turn back my regulator.  I love the idea that it regulates itself and frees you up.  Does it really do what it says it will?  I have become afraid of not getting enough oxygen and this would help eliminate a lot of my apprehension.

On the subject of me being too thin; I have loss most of my weight the last few years since I started working out so much.  I think I really eat a lot.  My body mass index is 19.1 and the good range for my age, height and weight is 18.5 to 24.9.  It does not say anything about % but if I read you right I need to get to the 24.9?  If this is true I guess I need to eat more.

Also the rehab here in Houston, did not push you that much.  They were good but they never ever gave you goals to obtain.  Is there a good exercise program for someone in my condition or a site I can go to that will help me stay as strong as possible.  Is there a book on exercise that would be good for COPD patients?

I am so glad I have found your website.  It has really inspired me to keep on keeping on.  You have so much knowledge and you are wonderful for sharing.

Lillian

Hi Lillian,

The smart Dose 'should' indeed be able to deliver the oxygen you need.  BUT, you can't rest on my guarantee, alone.  Get one and check your oxygen saturation during all manner of activities so that you can learn what it does for you. 

Remember, no matter what device or system you use - if you find that your saturation drops significantly AND there is no better system out there for you, realize that your next option is to slow down or stop and rest as needed to recoup and keep your saturation within therapeutic (and comfortable) levels. 

Remember, also, that exercise and the improved conditioning that comes through doing it will also help you breathe better AND improve your body's efficiency at using the oxygen that you CAN get into your system with your 'frumpy' lungs!

Best Wishes,

Mark

PFT Review  - COPD?

Hello Mark, Once again I seek your advice this is for my husband.  He was a very heavy smoker but gave up when he was 50, now he's 65.  He got worried as when he was doing some very hard work awhile back he felt he wasn't performing well and  got tired quicker than usual, so he saw my lung doctor who gave him a spirometry test.  The results were very good,  I write them here:  FVC 104.4 %, FEV1  102.3 %, FEV1 VC/MAX  106% PEF 129.5 %,  FEF25  97.5 %.   Now  FEF50 57.6%,  FEF75  42.7 %,  MMEF/7.5/25  69.9%.        I have written % as it's much easier.  However  the FEV1,FVC PEF are excellent for someone who smoked for 35 years, and the doctor hasn't given any treatment .  However, he doesn’t' understand why the other readings are so low, and indeed what these initials mean.  He feels these low % factors could be why he felt tiered when doing some very hard digging (with pickaxe)   Could you possibly explain to us the significance of low reading of FEF50 FEF75 and MMEF, when everything else is so good.   Thank you very much.  all the best,  Valerie

 

Hi Valerie,

Your hubby's airflow is GREAT!  And, accordingly, he has no evidence of 'clinically important' COPD.  That said, when you get to looking at FEF at 50 and 75 %, you are looking at airflow in the small airways - where evidence of COPD first shows.  AGAIN, that said, your hubby doesn't have changes significant enough to make the reductions in his small airway flow culpable in his complaints.  The MMEF is simply a reflection (relationship) of the expiratory flows reflecting the individual measurements as a comparison.

Much as I hate to suggest - your hubby is 65 years old.  And slinging a pick axe and doing the hard work you describe SHOULD make a man tired - even a younger man.  I would suggest that perhaps his expectations for himself and what he thinks he should 'easily' be able to do may be a bit inflated, when one considers age.   That he can manage to do that kind of heavy labor AND 'only' get 'very tired' is GREAT and would likely make many younger men feel a bit wimpy.

In any case, my bet is he'll be around for a long time and the likelihood of COPD becoming a significant difficulty in his life is quite doubtful.  Indeed, I suspect, he is one of those lucky ones who has the 'good jeans' that allow him to be in that percentage of the population that can smoke heavily and yet NOT develop COPD.

He needs to worry more about crossing the street in heavy traffic, playing golf in a thunder storm or getting shot by a jealous husband (or his lovely wife)  (thoroughly kidding on that last one, of course!) before he needs to fear COPD as any likely part of his foreseeable future.

So, tell him to keep slinging that pick axe AND exercise more for endurance-building, which will increase his tolerance of such strenuous activities!

Best Wishes, Mark

 

April 1st,  2012

Can You Recover from COPD?

Can my mom ever recover from copd?

Heather

Hi Heather,

Would that I could wave the magic wand to make your mom better, that is simply NOT in the cards.  COPD is a permanently damaging disease, irreversible at this time and progressive in nature.

The best we can hope for once one is diagnosed, is changes in lifestyle, effective treatment for symptoms and complications to slow the rate of progression.  It is very much a "move-it-or-lose-it" disease.  That one regain as much health and function and become every diligent in exercising to gain and maintain strength and improve symptoms is absolutely imperative.  It is also MUCH easier 'said' than 'done'! 

Because shortness and difficulty of breath and breathing are hallmark to the disease AND because challenging breathing with exercise and movement feel simply horrible as the disease progresses - and because such difficulties seem like they will harm one who continues to move while experiencing them - AND because those who care about the sufferer have difficulty watching the struggle, desiring to ease difficulties by doing more and more for them - there results a major hurdle to being able to effectively manage rate of progression with the singlemost effective means to doing so.

So, your quest is to help your mother get moving and keep moving.  She must learn that she CAN challenge her breathing, feel very bad doing so and still come out down the road in better shape than she was before AND in better shape than she would be if she didn't endure the difficulties of moving. 

Nutrition is of great importance to avoid dropping weight as time goe by, such that ideal body mass falls below 100 % of predicted for age, gender and height.  Using medications and - when the time comes that it is evident that oxygen becomes a necessary intervention - using oxygen properly are the other major components for keeping the rate of progression in check.

Keep asking questions and learning all you can.  Your role in helping your mother do well in spite of her disease is a very important one, indeed!

Best Wishes,

Mark

 

March 25, 2012

Mucus Problems

Hello Mark -
I have COPD and bronchiectasis diagnosed 9 years ago
I have been on oxygen for over 2 years, right now 2.5 LPM walking. 1.25 LPM sleeping
I cough between 200 and 300 times a day to remove mucus from my lungs
I am on 8 medications and use several machines to help me breathe
I use a VPap machine all night to help keep CO2 down
I am having more and more difficulty getting the mucus out as it's so thick and sticky.   
     I do use the little white pipe vibrating ball thing  which helps a bit
     My wife pounds my back 20 minutes a day
     I have been to the West Park Rehab. Centre for their full program

Any ideas for what else I can do to get this mucus out?  Thanks

John

Hi John,

You didn't say if you are using Mucinex or other preparation of guaifenesin.  If not, that might be worth trying.  Many folks find NAC (N-Acetyl Cysteine) a nutritional supplement (over the counter) of benefit in helping to thin mucus for easier expectoration.

Breathing steamy air (for those who can tolerate it) - as in a steamy bathroom - helps many folks to loosen and bring up mucus.

There are other more 'robust' positive pressure - with and without vibration - devices like Acapella, Resistex and others.  They exert a positive pressure - and in the case of Acapella, add vibration to your airways - during exhalation which helps to mechanically move mucus.  What you describe using is the "flutter" valve.  It is convenient, but doesn't exert a very forceful vibration.

There are several devices that are of a higher level of effectiveness - and cost - that do a much better job of moving mucus.  My first recommendation is one of two positive pressure devices.  MetaNeb is a device that delivers an aerosol and two levels of pressurized vibration. It is convenient and easy to use and less expensive than the next device I recommend. 

IPV (Intrapulmonary Percussive Ventilator) is a more robust version of MetaNeb.  It has a higher pressure and vibration capability and also delivers an aerosol with the vibration through positive pressure breathing.  It is very effective, though expensive.  And, while I think it is available in Canada, I don't know what the ability to get it covered by your health care benefits is.

Many recommend high frequency chest wall oscillatory vibration using one of the three versions of 'vests' that are on the market.  Personally, I don't like vest therapy (as much ballyhooed as it is most everywhere) as much as I like positive and negative ventilatory maneuvers provided by IPV, MetaNeb and the Hayek device (described in the next paragraph).  But, if the vest were to be all you could get, it would suffice. 

A new device finally on the market in the USA, but long available in Europe is the Hayek chest curiass high-frequency ventilation device.  It does pretty much the same thing as the IPV and MetaNeb, but does it with "negative" pressure on the outside of the chest wall, rather than exerting positive pressure against the airways internally, as with IPV.  I don't know the availability of that device in Canada, either.  It is VERY effective at moving mucus.

One other intervention worth discussing with your doctor would be the use of 'nebulized hypertonic saline'.  You breathe in saline that is about 7% concentration which pulls water into the mucus in your airways and thins it out.  This is used in the bronchiectasis we see in Cystic Fibrosis, but has similar application in non-CF bronchiectasis. 

At the very least, if your wife is pounding your chest (percussion) then you should ALSO be using postural drainage - positioning your lungs so as to recruit gravity to help 'drain' your airways.  There are lots of descriptions on-line for positions that would be effective for your needs.  If you are not using postural drainage with the percussion she gives you, then you are missing a big - FREE - piece of the puzzle that can help improve your mucus movement, immediately.  Be sure to do Postural Drainage and Percussion within 30 minutes after using your aerosol (nebulizer) medications for best mucus movement.

I hope somewhere in these thoughts you find something to add to your regimen.  If not, let me know and we'll see if we can think of yet others.

Best Wishes,

Mark

 

When Will Oxygen Be Required & What Does Moderate to Severe Mean?

Hello,

My husband has just been diagnosed with COPD Moderate to Severe.....what does that mean?....Can we expect to lead a normal life with this diagnosis ?...At what stage does a person with Mod-severe need oxygen.

Thank you for your help
Terri

Hi Terri,

I'm afraid I can't very well answer your questions beyond a general response because the term "moderately severe" or its variation "moderate to severe" as used in your hubby's case, tells me nothing specific.  Indeed, the days when "moderately severe" as a characterization or label for COPD was acceptable are LONG gone, having been replaced by a world-wide standardized severity grading system under GOLD (Global Initiative on Obstructive Lung Disease).  GOLD classifies severity of COPD in "stages" - stages I, II, III, IV according to FEV-1 and FEV-1/FVC ratios derived from pulmonary functions tests.

What will help is knowing what your husband's "FEV-1" measured on the pulmonary functions test (PFT) - a test he should have had done - that revealed his COPD diagnosis.  If he has NOT had a PFT, then a return to the doctor who made the diagnosis would be in order to demand that the test be done.  It is unconscionable to diagnose and treat someone who is said to have "moderately-severe COPD" without having first established the diagnosis with a properly performed PFT.  If indeed he DID have a PFT, then you should call and ask what his FEV-1 and FVC measured on that test. There should be absolutely NO reason why they would hesitate to give those numbers to you.  AND ALL COPD patients (IMO) should "know their numbers" (FEV-1 and FVC)!

Some times a physician will run a CT scan and make the diagnosis from that.  While a CT certainly "shows" the tissue changes of COPD, it in no way characterizes the "clinical" severity of the disease - a much more important and meaningful measure that tells us how well a person "functions" and is able to live life with their level of disease.

COPD is a progressive disease.   It will gradually worsen over the years.  The key to keeping the rate of progression as slow as possible is "movement"! COPD is a "move it or lose it" disease.  While moving can bring on significant breathing difficulties and symptoms, the trick is to learn that breathing hard and being VERY uncomfortable (1) will NOT hurt a person - even though it may FEEL like it will kill them (smile) and (2) will actually allow them to keep moving and functioning very well while improving the severity of breathing difficulties as they get in better shape and stay in that improved condition.

Oxygen is most often not part of the picture until one's COPD has reached an extreme level of severity.  An FEV-1 of less than 30 % is almost ALWAYS a necessity to see hypoxia (low oxygen levels in the blood) that requires oxygen therapy to correct.  Often the FEV-1 is found to be much lower for oxygen to be necessary, though necessity for use of oxygen is NOT specifically or obligatorily tied to FEV-1, per se.

So, if indeed your hubby falls into the category of "moderate to severe" as it 'used to be referred, he is still some years away from needing oxygen.  You didn't say how old he is or anything about his history (especially that of smoking).  So I am at a loss insofar as being able to ascertain anything that might be an influence of age.

So, the bottom line is you have a lot of good questions that cannot be answered until and unless you gather and provide much more information.  Feel free to come back and post your questions again once you have obtained the information I've suggested.

Best Wishes,

Mark

COPD & Sinus Infections

Is there any connection between COPD/Asthma and sinus infections. I was diagnosed with COPD last year and was prescribed DAXAS in
August. Since then, I have had ongoing sinus infections that cause runny nose, congestion and cough. I use a saline solution daily but
there is little improvement. Is the sinus problem a symptom of COPD or could it be the DAXAS. Appreciate your input....Ron

Hi Ron,

While folks who have COPD often have problems with sinus infections, that they are necessarily caused by or a necessary part of having COPD is not established.  Daxas does have some side effects of which rhinitis and sinusitis are included.  Your doctor should be able to tell you if Daxas is suspect in your difficulties.  As well  a consult to an ENT specialist should be of help in discovering the cause of your difficulties and perhaps a good course of treatment.  Don't simply stop the Daxas without first collaborating with your doctor(s) and looking for alternative solutions.

Best Wishes,

Mark

Daxas

I have had asthma for a number of years and was taking symbicort, singular and spiriva and they allowed me to carry on with my life in a normal fashion. Things changed last year, when I had pneumonia in January, later a viral infection that lasted two months and in  the spring I was experiencing difficulty breathing with many panic attacks. In August I was put on Daxas and despite some bad effects, my breathing improved. I have experienced  insomnia and I am presently taking trazodone with good sleep results. Since being on Daxas my sinus's are mildly infected most of the time with a runny nose and nasal congestion. Is this a common occurrence with Daxa`s.
I am using a saline solution 2-3 times a day and while this clears the nasal passages, this infection does not go away.
My latest breathing test in February indicated I was at 51% capacity. I still have breathing difficulty when exerting myself so I have been hesitant in doing any exercises although today I will give it a try on my treadmill.
Is Daxas the answer for long term management of COPD.

Ron

Hi Ron,

Since this post seems to be an elaboration on a previous post describing the same problem(s) and somewhat the same questions, I'm going to assume that you are the same Ron who posted the previous question.  If you are not one and the same person, I apologize for the erroneous assumption.  But, my response to that query holds true here, as well.

To answer your additional questions: Daxas is only one piece of the COPD management pie.  As such, it does not hold any broad benefit or singular basis for COPD management, but rather works with the other pieces to produce an overall improvement in symptoms.

With an FEV-1 of 51 % of predicted, you have PLENTY of lung capacity.  Even though you may experience some hard breathing with exertion, you should strive to exercise despite the hard breathing.  Indeed, you should target "achieving" significant windedness and work to breathe in order to improve your long term breathing and reduce the degree and impact of breathing difficulties and symptoms.  To decide not to exercise because of some mild breathing difficulty can be the kiss of death over the long run.  The more one avoids breathing hard with COPD, the faster it progresses and the sooner they die.  That may sound harsh.  But it's simple and it's true.  Don't get caught in that trap!

Best Wishes,

Mark

NAC

I see  people referring to NAC...what is it and what are its effects on COPD?

Heather

Hi Heather,

NAC is "N-Acetyl Cysteine".  In the body, NAC acts as an antioxidant.  In the lungs, it does two things that are of major benefit.  It helps mobilize mucus for better clearance from the lungs.  It also stimulates production of glutathione in the longs - an anti-inflammatory substance that decreases airway inflammation.  It is sold as a nutritional supplement and is recommended in doses of 1200 - 1800 mg/day along with 1000 - 2000 mg vitamin C which helps prevent the metabolites (in this case 'salts') of NAC from forming kidney stones.  It is generally a good thing for folks with COPD to consider using. 

Best Wishes,

Mark

Oxygen Eqpt & Usage

Mark,

I have COPD, I am 73 woman.  I am on Oxygen 24/7 for the last 2 years.  I am fine at home because I am on a concentrator to get my oxygen and on one at the gym where I do my exercises.  I actually turn it up to 5 liters to excercise to keep my blood oxygen in the 90s.  I am very thin, work out as much as I can when I am not sick.  Another words I am really trying to be as active as possible. 

Here is my problem.  To go out shopping etc. I carry a bottle of pressured oxygen with a regulator with a demand setting.  When the oxygen in the bottle drops down I can no longer pull the oxygen out.  I have tried two different types but I am not having any luck keeping my oxygen levels up when I start moving around.  Is there someone who can test me and find the right system for me so get out of the house and stay active for as long as I can.

I live in Houston, Texas.  I wish I lived in Colorada because things are more advanced there because of Dr. Petty.  I know there has got to be an answer for me.

Thanks for your help in advance.

Lillian

Hi Lillian,

First, you say you live in Houston, TX, but suggest that medicine and medical practice are somehow not up to date or up to par, let alone comparable to Denver, CO.  While Denver arguably has some world class lung facilities - and as Tom Petty played a large part in bring notoriety to Denver, his influence reaches far beyond Denver as a significant part of what we call the standard of care, today throughout the practice of pulmonary medicine.  Another point to consider is that Denver is at a mile high altitude which makes having lung disease AND hypoxia especially difficult, since that altitude carries it's own inherent set of negative influences on one's breathing and oxygenation!  Those who use oxygen require much more than those living closer to sea level like you in Houston and me in San Antonio!  

I would also remind you that Houston has some world class medical facilities and is no slouch in the medical field, by any means!  That doesn't mean that those who serve you aren't up to par with the general level of practice in Houston.  But, that is neither here nor there.  You have available all the services and quality of service you need right there in Houston!  So, let's see if we can help you with what information you need to obtain those quality services.

If you are very thin, I am concerned that you are maintaining sufficient body mass to keep your disease progression and symptoms to the minimum possible.  Check to see if your body mass meets predictions for "ideal body mass" for a person of your age, gender and weight.  If you are not greater than 95 % (and it would be better to be at or over 100 %) of your ideal body mass, then you need to put on some weight.  It is a common finding that folks who have advanced COPD (as indicated, especially in your case, by the need for oxygen 24/7) die sooner than they would if they had greater body mass AND they suffer worse symptoms during survival.  So, consider what influence your "thinness" may be exerting on your symptoms and even your need for how much oxygen you use.

If you need 5 liters of oxygen from your concentrator to maintain saturations in the 90's during exercise, then you surely need that equivalence when out and about using your portable oxygen system.  It is obvious that the conserver you are using is NOT putting out nearly the equivalent of 5 L/min compared to continuous.  In fact, there are only a few compressed gas conservers that can achieve that kind of output.  You need to ask for them specifically by name/model and accept NOTHING different, as other simply will not compare or measure up.  Puritan Bennett CR-50, Salter Labs O2Xpress and Inspired Technologies Smart Dose are really the only ones that can deliver the amount that you need.  Ask for them and have your saturation measured during several minutes of walking and activities similar to shopping, etc.

As well, understand that the size of the tank you use determines how long it will last.  If you are using M-250 also called B-cylinders, you must understand that using as much oxygen as you do when walking, they will not last but a couple of hours.  If you are walking then sitting for spells, be sure to turn DOWN the flow so as to stretch the supply for a longer duration. Try using C-cylinders and D-cylinders whenever possible.  Even putting an E-cylinder on a cart and schlepping it along behind you will increase your supply duration.

But, the natural and expected phenomenon of using the gas in the cylinder will result in the pressure drop you see to a point where you will not be able to get any more oxygen out of the tank simply because the pressure has dropped too low to power the delivery device.  This is usually somewhere at or below 150 pounds pressure in the tank.  So, the problem is NOT with the system or any malfunction.  You are simply observing the results of having used up all the usable oxygen in the tank and need to be prepared to change it out for a full one so you can continue your away-from-home activities.

You sound like you're working hard to keep yourself in the best shape you can.  Keep up the good work.  I hope this information will help you get a better portable oxygen system.

Best Wishes, 

Mark

Portable Oxygen Systems

Hi Mark...What do you know about the Helios Oxygen systems?  I want something very portable and very light while getting more time out of the unit before refill is needed.....I sure would also like continuous flow.....Let me know your thoughts.....hope you are having a good holiday....Thanks....Heather

Heather

Hi Heather,

Everyone wants the lightest oxygen system possible that delivers the most oxygen and lasts for a long time and can -provide continuous flow.  The fact is that unfortunately, this is truly one of those situations when you simply can't have your cake and eat it too!

Helios 300 is under 5 pounds - very light weight, indeed.  But is delivers ONLY pulsed oxygen - and not close to continuous flow equivalent, at that.  It lasts forever (10 hours at setting 2), but does so by delivering a stingy amount of oxygen along the way.  So, you get a long time of use, but are deprived of adequate oxygen while stretching the supply duration.

Helios Marathon is a bit larger and heavier, but delivers up to 6 liters of continuous.  The caveat is that at 6 liters continuous flow, you will use the supply in two hours.  so you sacrifice duration for the continuous flow feature.

With ANY liquid system (LOX), you will have to either return home for refills at intervals or carry a reservoir in your vehicle to refill from while out and about. 

Compressed gas cylinders offer some advantages in the categories you cite AND allow you to carry several cylinders for replenishment of supply without having to return to home base for refill, as with LOX.

Now a good conserving device will help you stretch ANY compressed gas system to as long or longer than LOX systems while still providing plenty of oxygen to keep you well-saturated.  Devices as I named for Lillian are those which I recommend for those who have significant oxygen demands during ambulation.  Take a look at my response to her for those device names and models. 

Best Wishes,

Mark

Heredity

My sister and I have both been diagnosed with Emphysema. She continued smoking and still has not quit. I quit smoking 3 years before I was diagnosed with COPD. My sister has recently been diagnosed with lung cancer and will off course be getting treatment. Does this mean that I am likely to have lung cancer eventually also? I am a 59 year old female and my sister is 61!

Linda

Hi Linda,

While heredity DOES play a significant role in who gets COPD and who doesn't and as you and your sister both have it suggests that heredity is at play in your family, that you will necessarily get cancer too, is not possible to predict or foresee.  You quit smoking sooner, so "may" have less proclivity to develop it.  At the same time, heredity could indeed play out such that you end up developing cancer somewhere down the line, too.

No one can say one way or the other.  All you can do is to continue to live as health and best as you can and stay as active as you can.  Don't live your life fearing and behaving to avoid getting cancer.  Live your life for the best each day can bring.  That way, if you DO someday develop cancer, you won't have regrets for wasting your time in the meantime.

Best Wishes,

Mark

Frequency of RT Visits

Hi Mark
My name is Marie and I was diagnosed with COPD June 2006. I am 64yrs old.
I took the Pulmonary Rehab course with Surrey Memorial Hosp and continue on a maintenance program with the YMCA in Surrey BC

The last time I saw my RT, she told me I did not have to comeback as my lungs had not changed in 2 years. She said to keep doing what I am doing.

My GP has some knowledge of my condition.
I used to use oxygen on exertion and overnight, I am finding that I no longer need if for exertion and am looking to be tested for that again soon.

My question is do you think it is ok that I am no longer seeing my RT and I should I continue to listen to my body and carry on.

Thank you
Marie

Hi Marie,

It sounds like you are doing fine.  I would suggest seeing who you think you need to see at intervals that "you" are most comfortable with.  Keep up your exercise at the YMCA. 

Why not purchase an oximeter to measure your saturation under multiple conditions to be sure you do or do not need oxygen any longer.  Oximeters are cheaper now than they've ever been, running as low as about $40!   To simply stop using oxygen because you "feel" you don't need it is not a good idea as you could be desaturating to levels of concern during exertion and not feel it.  Going by feeling is NOT a good method for determining when to use oxygen.

Best Wishes,

Mark

 

March 4th, 2012

I Have Emphysema

I have been told that I have emphysema and that there is nothing to do about the disease except the usual  puffers  ? May I have your comments ,please ??

Ken

Hi Ken,

To say that there is "nothing to do about the disease is a complete mischaracterization of the facts!  While the "puffers" you speak about are  mainstay of the inhaled medication management of symptoms of the disease, they are not the only medications that may be of  value.  At the same time, there is no 'magic bullet' that can stop the progression or reverse the tissue damage or the like.  COPD (which includes chronic bronchitis and emphysema as predominant diagnoses under the umbrella term)is a progressively deteriorating disease, the rate of which can be slowed by proper nutrition, exercise and smoking cessation, among other things.  Folks can easily live 20 and 30 or more years with COPD before it becomes bad enough to cause their demise.

So, to say that there's nothing more than the puffers to do about COPD is simply wrong and short-sighted.  Folks who sit around, do nothing and feel sorry for themselves will deteriorate rapidly and be miserable in their remaining time alive.  That doesn't have to be.  Indeed, next week, I am cruising the Caribbean for 10 days with the SeaPuffers - a group of folks who have advanced COPD who ALSO use oxygen therapy.  They are FAR from giving up or even slowing down because of their now-advanced disease!  So, it will be what you make of it - no more and no less!

Best Wishes for a bright future DESPITE having COPD, Ken!

 Mark

Oxyview Glasses

If you are using pulse dose can you still get oxyview glasses or does it need to be continuous?
Tom

Hi Tom,

The answer is: It all depends . . . "  It depends upon which pulsed dose device you are using and how sensitive it is to being triggered by your inspiratory effort.  If you contact the folks who make OxyView spectacles, they should be able to tell you, if you tell them what machine you use.  If not, ask if you can demo a pair or get a guarantee for your money back if they don't work for you.  I have known the makers of OxyView to be very accommodating and reasonable with their customers.

Best Wishes,

Mark

Undetermined Diagnosis

Hi
First of all I would like to describe my health issue's. I have been coughing for a very very long time and I have had the pulmonary test done by Dr Rahimi and she ruled out asthma. I have had my sinuses surgery last year Mar 24,2011 by Dr Turner.  I also had the tube put down my throat to check for things and he did not see anything wrong with my throat area.  Dr Telang did a esophagus test and seems to think that my esophagus is not working the way it should. 
So my family Dr Pratt has put me on inhalers to help me breath and it does not always do the job.  I have been on the inhalers for a long time now and I want to know how safe it is to be on the inhalers like that.  My cough is a wet and very rattling cough; especially on my left side it really rattles and I can feel it rattle and my husband hears me at nite when we are asleep. I have had this for so long and not sure what to do any more.  I cough all the time and I am tired of it. My inhalers are APO-salvent(blue inhaler) I take this one every 5 hours or so 2-3 puffs and my other one I take at nite to help me is Alvesco -2 puffs at nite before bed. I get SOB lots and it is scary when you can't get your breath. I think that I may have  bronchitis because my Dad used to cough a bit if I remember. I just don't want to cough any more.
My question is I don't know what to do anymore I am at the end of my rope and so tired of it all and I want to know where do I go to really check into this and if it is safe to be on inhalers every day?   I have ask Dr Pratt to help me but I am not so sure she can. I wish I could just get one Dr to help me out and believe me.

Jean

Hi Jean,

I'm sorry to hear of your difficulties.  Are you telling me that while your doctors have ruled out asthma as a problem, they have not given you ANY diagnosis?  Have they mentioned bronchitis, or chronic bronchitis, since you speak of having lots of mucus production?

Have they opined that perhaps your sinuses are culpable in your cough and mucus production - a fairly common occurrence  in folks who have significant sinus illness?

If your cough were dry and hacky, I'd suspect the potential for an interstitial diseased process, like pneumonitis of some kind or a collagen tissue disease or fibrosis process, or something.  Those types of ailments are detectable using high-resolution CT scan.  So, if you haven't had one of those, then that might be worth asking about.  You say you've had the breathing tests.   But, you didn't say what ANY of your numbers were.  Do you know what your FEV-1, FVC  and TLC and/or DLCO were found to be on that pulmonary functions test (PFT)?

In the end, I can't tell you much of anything because you only vaguely described the testing you had done and didn't provide any "numbers" to tell me specifically, or in lingo "I" can understand what might be going on.

In any case, it is safe to use inhalers for many, many years.  Many folks have safely used inhalers - in some cases, the same ones - for well over 15 and 20 years.

Best Wishes, Mark

Working in a Manufacturing Plant

I have just been diagnosed with copd, and I work in a furniture manufacturing plant with saws sanders and other industrial size machines is it still possible to keep working at that job, I haven't smoked cigarettes for about 7 years, thank you. I'm 53 years old

Chris

Hi Chris,

There is no reason why you should give up your work, especially if you love doing it.  You SHOULD and MUST take precautions to interrupt the exposure to the harmful inhalants you undoubtedly have taken into your lungs so as to minimize and further exposure or danger of reaction to inhaling those substances.

Stay away from glues and varnishes in poorly ventilated areas.  Wear a mask to filter out sawdust and small particles. so you don't continue to inhale them.  They are your worst enemy, by far.  Use your inhalers.  Get plenty of exercise.  Stay balanced in body mass and nutrition,  Exercise to optimize your physical condition and stamina.

Best Wishes,

Mark

February 26, 2012

Alpha 1 Test

Can you explain the benefits of getting the  Alpha 1 Anti-Trypsin-Deficiency blood test? I have also heard that a person should look into having tests to check the functioning of the thyroid, especially, if, as I do, have hypothyroidism and have had for years.  Thank you, Dianne

Dianne

Hi Dianne,

Not too long ago, Aplpha-1-Antitryosin Deficiency Emphysema (the genetic form of Emphysema/COPD) was considered to be a fairly rare disease and one that not only did we not know much about, but had little ability to treat, short of drastic measures like lung transplant and enzyme replacement therapy.  As our understanding grew AND we saw new, more effective treatments coming to market, we increasingly realized that the disease is far more prevalent than we had earlier thought, indeed, a LOT more prevalent.  When the blood test to identify those with the defect became available, it was found to be easy to do, very accurate and not expensive (for most, it is free).   It has become increasingly clear that the only responsible thing to do today when someone presents with COPD, especially which is primarily emphysema and also especially if (1) they have insufficient history to suggest predisposition to developing COPD (smoking history, certain occupational or environmental influences, etc) AND if they are under the age of 60 at diagnosis or advanced stage, then they should be tested for the disease.

We know today that the sooner one is diagnosed, the better chance to treat and control it we have.

As far as the thyroid test you ask about, it may be true that if you or someone in your family has thyroid disease, you have a history of thyroid dysfunction or you have symptoms suggestive of a thyroid disorder, you should get checked and perhaps with regularity to detect problems and monitor interventions.  As far as one needing to check their thyroid function because of any connection to having COPD, I am not aware of any such correlation.

Best Wishes,  Mark

Lung Condition Summary

I have severe copd condition, my lung capacity is less than 50%.
Since last Sunday I have been on prednisone 50 mg and co azithromycin 250 mg
for exacerbation.
My shortness of breath and coughing has been increasing daily for a few weeks.
I have other problems with my lungs, such as unknown nods .Have had a broncoscopy a needle biopsy
and they are considering an open lung biopsy, I have had kidney and prostate cancer, worried about metasis .
I also have sleep apnea.
With my condition the open lung biopsy is probably questionable.
I have seen pulmonologist and urologist on a regular basis. Awaiting  to hear from them,
saw both last week.
I am an almost 77 year old grandfather.  Larry

Hi Larry,

You told me lots of good information about you and your condition.  But, after reading it over a few times, I don't see a question in there.  Do you have a question for me regarding your condition or anything within the information you provided?

If so, please try again next week and be sure to ask your question!  I'll do my best to give you an answer.

Best Regards, Mark

COPD or Asthma?

My respiratory problems have GREATLY increased since I underwent 2 yrs. of chemotherapy (Rituxan, Cytoxan, Fludara) for Non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma (which is now in remission).
 
I've been told for about 12 yrs., that I had asthma, and it was pretty well controlled with Advair250.  In the fall though, I would usually get a bad case of bronchitis.

Then came the chemo.  In the middle of the 1st round of it, bad bronchitis emerged.  They gave me drugs to help, and we finished that round.  Four rounds and 2 yrs. later, the same thing always happens:  bad bronchitis emerges during the round, and lingers longer and longer with each round.  Since this last round (Dec. of 2010), I have been sick (bad cough, mucus, a bit of SOB) more often than not.  My oncologist minimized it.  He sent me to his favorite pulmonologist, who said "mild obstructive lung disease:  COPD/Asthma" but stressed COPD in our discussion.  The onc. & pulmo. are in NYC and I'm an hour away in New Jersey, so I also have a local pulmonologist whom I can get to when sick - his diagnosis, "asthma".

I have had spirometry, gases etc. by both pulmo's, and 2 chest CT's ("mild emphysema" shows on both, "ground glass" and "pneumonitis" only on 1st).  I smoked 1 pk.of cigarettes per day for 20 yrs., but quit smoking totally 21 yrs. ago.

I don't understand the "asthma" diagnosis, as my spirometry shows little change before and after bronchodilator.  I also don't understand the "COPD" diagnosis, as my spirometry is essentially normal (by my understanding of GOLD standards).  On Jan. 20th, 2011, just as I was getting another bit of bronchitis, this was my "after" spirometry:

FVC (L)             = 4.60 / 101% predicted    %Chg -1
FEV1 (L)           = 3.25 / 102% pred.           %Chg -1
FEV1%              = 71 / 101% pred.              %Chg 0
FEV25-75 (L/S) = 2.07 / 69% pred.             %Chg -6
PEF (L/S)          = 9.30 / 108% pred.           %Chg 4
FET (S)             = 8.71                                %Chg 11

So, from my understanding, the spirometry is good (except for low FEV25-75).

Does this look like asthma or COPD, or both (or neither)???

The worst part is I keep getting the bronchitis, over and over, and am on Advair, Spiriva, Albuterol as needed, Prednisone tablets as needed when sick.  Sometimes the only thing that makes it better is the Prednisone.

I am confused about the diagnosis, and my life is much more limited from the now frequent bouts of bronchitis.

Sorry for the long question, but it's my 1st one (and I've also become a bit afraid as to my future - things seem out of control).

Thank you,
Don

Hi Don,

According to your numbers, I don't see any evidence of Asthma OR COPD.  at greater than 100 % of the two most important values measured (FEV1 & FVC) and inview of the other measures you reported (including the 69 % FEF 25-75) nothing even suggests reactive airways disease (asthma) OR COPD.  So, I disagree with both diagnoses - especially in view of the CT scans and your history of exacerbation of your symptoms.

First, with the numbers you have, you shouldn't be having any breathing difficulties that are generated by any influence of lung function.  It is also possible that (1) you indeed have VERY MILD reactive airways disease that is absolutely 'normalized' by your medications or (2) your symptoms of difficulty breathing are a paradoxical response to the Advair which may be 'early-kill' or 'over-kill' for such mild disease, if it even exists.

Now the CT findings and the fact that ALL of your bronchitis episodes have onset during the middle of immunosupression therapy for your cancer are highly suspicious for a combination of infectious response to 'opportunistic pathogens' ("bugs") AND the finding of interstitial pneumonitis and ground glass appearance screams of just that diagnosis.  It also stands to reason why you feel better when you take prednisone.  You have had enough episodes that your pneumonitis has likely become a permanent feature of your lung tissue profile.  That being the case, you are subject to repeat bouts of bronchitis without need for immunosupression like that imposed during chemotherapy.  It is not surprising that the oncologist shrugs it off.  Those chemo agents (cytoxin, especially) are known to have an effect (interstitial pneumonitis and fibrosing changes) on the lungs.  Unfortunately, this is one of those times where the benefit outweighs the risk as in your case, it has out your N-HL in remission - a very good thing. 

Ask your doctors about trying the following: stop the Advair for a few weeks.  See what happens to your breathing.  Use the prednisone for perhaps a bit longer and at low dose and then repeat your PRE and POST spirometry in a month and see how it looks.  If your values drop be 20 % and you get a response of greater than 10 %, you will be able to say there is significant airway reactivity.  BUT, if in the interim, you get to feeling and breathing better without the Advair, then the question becomes which is worse, a bit of airway reactivity that doesn't produce significant symptoms or enduring chronic amplified symptoms secondary to a medication that you arguably may not need to be taking.

Best Wishes, Mark

Very Severe COPD & Exercise

Hi Mark,I have severe copd.on 02 3yrs.I am 5 1yrs old and have had copd for 5 yrs or longer quit smoking  yr go .have trouble walking, but you explained that to me last week. I go only 50 ft.Saw my pulmonary Dr. last week.My fev1 has dropped to 11%i feel sick about that.I thought I would of got better as last yr it was 17.Ithe Dr. said don't worry about the numbers,worry about exercising .I do not go far. She said try to go 3 times per day. I know I need to move it. I bought oximeter through membership and keep an eye when on treadmill but my heart goes too high.145.the Dr's never said anything about it high. It is between 115-120 when sitting. I am waiting ekg.Eating healty,fruits veggies fish etcMy family Dr. put me on a lot of b vitamins   and iron were low.Please help Sue in Ontario I am scared if m fev goes lower, my Dr said we cant do any thing about the numbers?

Susan

Hi Susan

It is clear that you have very severe COPD, with such a low FEV-1.  Your numbers speak volumes to your symptoms and having great difficulty breathing, especially with movement.  Nevertheless, it is imperative that you find a way to get moving more and keep moving DESPITE the breathing difficulties that moving elicit.  That your resting heart rate is 110 and more says that your basic physical condition if very poor.  That ADDS to your breathing difficulties and CASN be improved with better conditioning.  But, as you well know, it is easier said than done.  At the same time, NOTHING else will potentially improve your condition, symptoms and function.  So, you must find a way to put your nose to the grindstone and learn to overcome the temptation to stop and or do nothing for fear of the breathing difficulties.  It WON'T hurt you to breathe hard.  And until and unless you can bring yourself to put up with the breathing difficulties AND keep moving, you cannot expect to have a chance to improve.  It's a tall order, I realize.  But, it is the ONLY way to a better life.  Don't worry about the 145 heart rate unless if causes symptoms in and of itself that become dangerous.  Talk to your doctor about that and what you should look for and avoid.  Be sure to use PLENTY of oxygen when exercising.  ANY drop in your oxygen level (say, below 93 %), will greatly amplify your breathing symptoms.  So, as much as is possible, you should try to use enough to keep your saturation as high as possible so as to move as much and as long as possible at a spell.

Best Wishes, Mark

Pleural Pain

I have COPD.  I was admitted to hospital with pneumonia.  I was released Feb. 7.  I have completed the antibiotic and  prednisone regime I was prescribed.  I take spiriva, advair and singulair for my condition.  In addition, I take zoloft, xalatan, and zopoclone.  I am working to get well.  On or about Feb 12, I developed to a pain.  It is a nagging pain that is located in the location of my right breast and goes through to my back.  The pain at times is a catching pain that will cause me to utter out involuntarily.  I attended to my family physician Feb 16.  he examined my chest and said that it was clear, not rattling or wheezing .   He believed that the pain was cause by the pleura that was being disturbed and causing the pain.  When in hospital, I was visited by  a  respirologist  in hospital and he said I had a lot of damage to my right lung.  I have a lot of tests scheduled in May.  Meanwhile, I am wondering if the pain I have now will gradually subside or could it be something else.

Elaine

Hi Elaine,

Your pain sounds pleruitic to me, too.  All I can say is that we need to wait for you to complete those tests, as anything at this point would be wild speculation and not helpful with regard to anything you could or should be doing to help or avoid it.  Let's see what the tests show.

Best Wishes, Mark

Spirometry Numbers Definitions

What do FEV1 and FEV5 mean?   I notice you people using these abbreviations and am stumped...is there somewhere I can go to get all this translated?   Someone has most likely already asked this but I am rather new to the site.....

Heather

Hi Heather,

What you mean rather than FEV"5" is FEV"6".  FEV6 is the same value by definition as FVC that you'll find in any set of references using FEV.  FEV1 is a forced expiratory maneuver that measures how much air you can blow out with your most maximal effort in the first second of your exhalation, when the measurement maneuver is performed. 

For a good explanation of all the types of tests done to obtain an assessment of one's pulmonary function, go to the following link and peruse the site.  For specific definitions and values of these two and other "spirometry" measurements, click on the link in the "spiromnetry" section that says "main article: Spirometry".  This is actually one of those times when of all the references I perused looking for one that is easily understood by a novice and lay person, Wikipedia actually turns out to be better, IMHO.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pulmonary_function_test

Best Wishes, Mark

You might also want to try http://copdcanada.ca/pft_numbers.htm

The Use of Fans

Does a fan help? 

(Q extracted from the Message Board)

And, can a COPD’er in fact breathe in their own CO2 enough when they’re laying/ sleeping (assuming their face isn’t covered with blankets) that it would have a negative effect?

It has long been observed that a significant portion of the COPD population shows preference for air blowing at their face or simply circulating the air in the room.  Indeed, the worse the person's FEV-1, the more they gravitate to fans as an adjunct (common observation among my professional colleagues and a good observation by the nurse mentioned by a respondent when she was in the hospital).  What ever the reason for benefit - reduction of claustrophobic sensations, facial cooling, trigeminal nerve stimulation, etc., the fact remains that despite definitive evidence of source of benefit, the response from those who rely on the method is consistent: "reduction of dyspnea."   

The notion that CO2 plays a part may have some validity to it but most certainly NOT from  any consideration of "stale air", lack of available oxygen or "re-breathing" exhaled air, as suggested by so many of the respondents.  One needs to understand the physics and chemistry of air to realize the impossibility of re-breathing under all but some very specific conditions (like breathing into a bag, as has been used over the decades to help thwart panic attacks in those who suffer them from a cause of hyperventilation).

The content of CO2 in the air is less than 1 % - virtually negligible, as a CO2 as high as 7.6 mmHg partial pressure would stimulate increased breathing in those with normal lung function (the 1 % threshold at sea level).  CO2 levels coming out of the lungs are a little under 6 % with dissipation and, consequently, dissolution occurring in a matter of milliseconds.  An example of the rapidity of dissolution is the respondent who was dysgenic in the "aisles of the grocery store, where air volume is monstrous compared to that in a closed car.  Yet, when she got closer to the door, her anxiety and dyspnea became noticeably decreased.  Yet no difference in available air volume occurred.  Then, when she went and sat in the car, her dyspnea went away completely.  That had everything to do with a psychological response to claustrophobia and nothing to do with air volume or availability of "fresh air" which necessarily was "LESS" in the car than ANYWHERE in the grocery store.  The warm feelings, etc, she experienced when her anxiety level rose in the tall-shelved aisles was a sympathetic nervous response, NOT the result of lack of fresh air to breathe.  That scenario exemplifies the strong effect that folks experience that can lead them to the erroneous conclusion that the force was 'real' and 'environmentally mediated', rather than what in fact occurs and is owing to psychological forces and influences.

But, unless one had the covers in bed over their head, the chance for re-breathing significant amounts of exhaled air is simply impossible.  The high collar sweaters and all, simply do not produce the effect cited by respondants.

So, the question becomes: "How can CO2 potentially play a part in the equation?"  As one with increasingly lower FEV-1 experiences dyspnea  and breathes faster in their effort to overcome it (tachypnea), they tend to move to the phenomenon of "dynamic hyperinflation" which by its mechanical effect causes an increase in CO2 in the blood because of less efficient clearance of CO2 resulting from the dynamic hyperinflation.  Saturation can be observed to decrease - not because oxygen levels drop, but because CO2 rises.  When CO2 rises, its influence on the acidity of the blood cause saturation to drop from ventilation-related causes, NOT from oxygenation related causes (another example of how saturation measurements do not reflect ONLY the influences of the amount of oxygen in the blood).  

The abstract is good information and has the best presentation of valid evidence, though difficult to confirm.  The contention with regard to the clinical practice guideline cited, that evidence is lacking to make the recommendation for using fans as a therapeutic intervention is just that:  There isn't enough evidence to support a scientific basis to make the recommendation.  That some like it and some can't stand it makes a case for a hard and fast recommendation unsupportable.

So, in the end, the choice needs to be left to the user and justification or explanation left to remain a mystery.  It is truly a situation where the adage applies: "If it feels good, DO IT!" 

February 19, 2012

Unusual Oxygen Saturation Readings

Mark,
  Firstly, you offer an amazing service! I have asked you questions before. Briefly, I am a 48 year old female with a 4 year history of shortness of breath on exertion. I have had elevated pulmonary pressures of 48 to 50 but a right heart cath showed a mean of 18 which is normal. My PFT's have been borderline normal. Last October, I had a TIA and the MRI showed 3 previous strokes. They do not know what caused them. I recently started cardiac rehab and the physiotherapist got me on the treadmill with a sat monitor. My sats are normal at rest but within minutes of walking, they dropped to 83%. My heart rate gradually increased accordingly and seemed accurate. They physio tried it on every finger but it stayed the same. As soon as I stopped walking, my sats went up to 100. The monitor was sitting in a holder so it wasn't moving and I was holding on to the treadmill so my finger wouldn't move. The scale on the left on the monitor would turn red when the numbers started to drop and then would fluctuate from red to green. The physio didn't know what to think. I was short of breath but I always am when exercising. This happened a couple of years ago and when the doctor repeated it with a different monitor, it did not happen. I hate to ignore it in case it might have something to do with these strokes. What do you think? Could it just not be picking it up? And if not, why?

Lori

Hi Lori,

I am concerned about your reported symptoms and what measurements you also have been found to have.  While a mean of 18 mmHg PA pressure may be normal, the fact that measures of systolic PA pressure are 48 - 50 is nevertheless abnormal and disturbing in themselves - also, especially in view of your elevated heart rate, shortness of breath and possible desaturation on exertion.

First, there may be a problem with the quality of measurement when your physiotherapist uses the finger oximetry.  You say that your fingers are not moving during the measurements that drop to 83 % and that motion is not a factor.  BUT, you are not considering "circulation artifact" which results from the variation in blood flow to (all) your fingers during "gripping" of the treadmill handrail.  The pressure exerted during gripping the rail impedes circulation to your fingers by compression of the 'palmer arch' AND digital arteries that branch off that arch.  The observation of the alternating signal quality strength light between red and green suggests that circulation artifact may indeed be at play.  As well, if your doctor did his/her measurements when you weren't gripping a hand rail, it would be no surprise that the same phenomenon didn't occur, back then.  But, since that was a "few years ago", it likely has little, if any, bearing on what's going on today as a lot can change in your condition over a couple of years time.

Next time your physiotherapist measures your saturation while you walk on the treadmill, release your grip and let your arm hang at your side.  No movement, no gripping, as still as possible.  See what happens then.  If the signal strength light stays green AND your heart rate goes up AND your saturation goes down, then you need to report that to your doctor, again.  With the fluctuations in PA pressures and their being elevated to 50 AND desaturation, tachycardia and tachypnea during exertion that are more than expected, you need to be evaluated further for pulmonary hypertension.  AND, if that doesn't appear to be significant, then a diffusion study to see if you have a restrictive lung disorder should be considered and likely done.  Another thing that might be worth considering doing during the right heart cath or at least during an echocardiogram would be to inject an IV dose of adenosine to simulate exercise and see it your PA pressures increase to more than 50 and/or your saturation drops with the increased cardiovascular stimulation.

Ultimately, I don't think your pulmonary hypertension and lung difficulties have a direct bearing or effect upon the TIA/stroke situation.  But, if you are over weight or have diabetes or systemic hypertension, those kinds of things will usually play a part in one's propensity towards cerebral-vascular problems.  Consider those points in deciding if you have risk that can be reduced with regard to avoiding future cerebro-vascular incidents.

Best Wishes,

Mark

 

February 12th, 2012

How Does Prednisone Work?

Without being too technical….

 

Let’s say you’re on 50 mg of Pred per day for a week to help reduce inflammation and SOB.

 

I’m trying to grasp “how/why”  Prednisone can increase a person’s FEV1.   Is the increase “above” what their “normal” FEV1 is

  and does that always happen?

 

I realize it’s a “temporary” increase but how long does the increase usually last once you stop taking it?

 

Many thanks,

J

Prerdnisone is an anti-inflammatory medication.  As such it reduces swelling in the airways.  Less swelling means greater airway lumen.  Greater airway lumen means easier air movement with less work.  With COPD, the greater airway lumen also means less air-trapping.  So, the net effect is an increase in FVC and FEV-1.  The effect lasts as long as you are on the prednisone and while it may not hold after ceasing prednisone, some measure of the gain realized during the prednisone regimen "can" be retained.

Best . . . Mark 

Stage IV COPD & Ativan for Anxiety

Good Morning Mark

I have not asked you any questions for awhile. I read you questions and answers with great interest. My husband Fred has End Stage COPD things most of the time are the same. This past weekend we did something stupid, we never checked his puffer closely and he was not feeling good for about two days. One night he started to get very anxious and it got worse I called the ambulance and the ambulance attendees said Fred blood pressure was 180 over 110, I got scared. They took him to the hospital and did the Ventolin and Atrovent puffers after a short time he was fine. His Saturation was 85 when they took him to the hospital and after a bit his saturation was back  to 95 which is very good for Fred. Now the stupid mistake we did was one of his puffer the Symbicort was on empty. We figure it was empty for about 2 days,  anyway it took him a day but he is fine again.
Now after this story the Dr gave Fred some Ativan to take he does get anxious easily. After a short time Fred  seems to be dependent on Ativan whenever things go wrong. Now do you know if many ppl with end stage copd take Ativan, I am a little leery of the drug but also is it addictive.
Please understand I do not question my Dr's diagnosis the only thing is when we spent 3 months at rehab and I stayed with Fred every day for 3 months to learn about this disease I don't remember anyone talking about Ativan.

Hope I explained myself correctly.

Thanks Mitch

Hi Mitch,

 

You did just fine explaining your difficulties.  While Ativan would not be 'my' favorite choice for anxiety control, it IS effective.  It is also habit-forming.  So, you suspicions are well-founded as are your concerns.  At the same time, many of the anti-depressants/anxiolytics are habit-forming.  So, it ends up being kind of a "pick your poison" dilemma.  If Fred seems to be using what you fear is becoming an excessive amount of Ativan (look at the prescription to see what he "can take" as a regular amount and maximum), talk with him and especially with the prescribing doctor.  If it becomes a significant concern insofar as how much he's requiring, then his doctor can consider other medications with less consequences.  Buspirone is a non-addictive anxiolytic.  But, it doesn't always work too great for some folks.  And in ALL folks, it must be taken for several days to build up a blood level that is effective for the individual.  It "can" be taken along with drugs like Ativan which can then be weaned down or phased out once the Buspirone has reached stable effectiveness.

 

In the meantime, try to work with him to exert conscious effort to control daily anxiety so that his need for medication is minimized.  And, be sure he doesn't run out on his inhalers again!

 

Best Wishes,

 

Mark

 

February 5th, 2012

The Best Place to Live with COPD

I know each person with copd/emphysema has a different set of symptoms, so a lot depends on that. However, I'm looking at different areas to possibly relocate to and there is a lot of conflicting information on the internet.

I live in the midwest. Cold dry winter bothers me--surprisingly hot humid summer does not (I don't hang-out outside though in the hot, humid weather). Humidity does bother me from the shower, though.

Can you state which climates/states might have clean air and ideal weather for copd/emphysema? I'm in my 50's have severe emphysema but still work full-time and function pretty well.

Thanks.
Moe

Hi Moe,

The question you ask comes up quite often.  I'm afraid that I simply don't have an answer for you.  That is also why you are finding so much confusing and contradictory information when you search the internet.  The fact is, there is no "ideal" location for those with chronic lung disease because their sensitivities vary so much.

My usual advice to folks is, it you don't like where you live, pick a few locations where you think you might like to live.  Visit those locations for at least a week - preferably during those segments of the year when you might be most sensitive to climatic and seasonal influences that affect folks' breathing and symptoms.  If you find a place that seems to strike your fancy, go there a couple of times at different times of year and make sure they are better suited to your needs, as best you can.

In any case, I recommend AGAINST jumping and moving without careful investigation an taking what may seem a lot of time (a year or so) to make a better educated decision.

Best Wishes,

Mark

 

January 29th, 2012

Spirometry Results Reviewed

Spirometry test: I had this test today at work. I took the test twice. First set of results were FVC 5.90 FEV1 1.97 FEV1% .33 . 2nd set of results were FVC 6.08 FEV1 2.13 FEV1% .35.

I am a 44yr old male who does not smoke. I weigh 233lbs and do snore at night. I was told I should see my internist regarding these results as they were not good. Just wondering what these results could mean.

Thanks for any input you can offer

Rick

 

Hi Rick,

 

First, it sounds like you had a ‘screening test’ to identify those who should be evaluated further for “potential” problems with lung disease.  The veracity of that test you underwent is dependent upon the skill of the person who conducted it, the integrity of the spirometer they used and its calibration and the quality of your effort.  Missing in your information that is key for my ability to interpret your numbers is your height.  If you are 6’4” (193 cm) tall, then 223 lbs (101.3Kg) is not bad.  But, if you are 5’6” (167.6 cm), then your weight could play a significant role in reducing your FEV-1.  It is your FEV-1 that appears, on first glance, to be significantly reduced and presenting suggestion that you may have airways disease of some kind.  But, not knowing how tall you are makes such assessment impossible, from where I sit.  As well, that you say you snore is in itself a worrisome problem and can lead to reactive airways disease among other problems if indeed a clinically significant problem – like having the presence of obstructive sleep apnea.

From the results you report, you seem to have performed the test adequately.  One factor that was NOT evaluated was if you have any airway reactivity (a.k.a. Asthma).  When we see someone like you in the clinical laboratory who produces numbers like you did AND who has no obvious contributory history for lung disease, we ALWAYS do a “post-bronchodilator” repeat spirometry study to assess for “reversibility of obstruction.  

 

In any case, you SHOULD follow up with your doctor.  Have a more controlled and better quality PFT (pulmonary functions test) done that repeats those measurements (3 times, each) after inhaling some bronchodilator medicine.  If you produce the same results AND have reversibility, then you have some degree of ‘asthma’ which can likely be treated and controlled.  You should also request a sleep study to determine if you have sleep apnea.  If you do, then getting that treated and controlled is imperative as it can cause high blood pressure, heart disease, diabetes and obesity, in and of itself!

 

Best Wishes,

 

Mark

 

Condensation when Nebulizing

 

Dear Mark,

When I take ventolin nebules with a mask, I get white droplets from my nose dripping back into the little cap. The solution becomes cloudy white.
What would be the cause of this?    Thank you, Madeline
 

Hi Madeline,

 

Most often, those drops are condensation of the nebulized fluid.  Because they are mixed with a lot of air bubbles (too small to see with the naked eye), they make the fluid appear to be white in color.  The solution turns white for the same reason.  As solution is taken up into the nebulizing mechanisms and “smashed” against the ‘baffle’ to break drops up into minute droplets which can then travel to the depths of your lungs, they fall back into the solution and make it appear to be a white color.

 

Now, if the solution were to change consistency (become thicker or ‘slimy’) that could be due to mucus flowing back into the nebulizer.  While I would say it is unlikely, it’s not impossible. 

 

In any case, the effectiveness of the solution shouldn’t be changed by what you observe.  Be sure to clean your nebulizer (rinse with water and air dry) after each treatment and thoroughly wash it at least once a week with soap and water and a disinfecting agent (dilute vinegar or very dilute bleach or commercial disinfecting product made specifically for inhaled medication devices [quaternary ammonia, for instance]).

 

Best Wishes,

 

Mark

 

Hi Mark,

Sorry to beat this desaturation thing to death, but I just realized something. When doing extreme exercising by doing plb helps to keep the numbers up.

I am going to presume that when you plb and can NOT increase the numbers then you are in a bit of trouble.

I ran into a gentleman at one of the long term care homes that i visit, and he is 84, and has been on 02 for 20 years. He is in a wheelchair but not in bad shape.

As mentioned Mark one can not get a script for 02 until the 02 levels are consistently below 88, and that has to be most of the time either when exercising
or just sitting or both.

Yesterday while at the computer my 02 was 97. I think I have a way to go yet without needing 02 on a daily basis.

Thanks Mark for all your help.  Philip

Desaturation & Oxygen Needs

Hi Philip,

No apology needed!  I think you’ll likely beat that horse for some time to come as you think of yet new and different – or just different angles of consideration to approach it with questions.  And, who knows, there are likely other folks who might be wondering the same things that you wonder about.  So, let’s go for it!

What you have discovered about PLB is precisely what we say is one of the potential benefits of using the technique.  And, you are absolutely correct, when it doesn’t work to improve your oxygen, you are indeed in “a bit of trouble”!  At that point, you need to use oxygen to raise your saturation – IF it has dropped to or below qualifying levels.

I suspect you are correct in your assessment that you probably don’t need to worry about needing oxygen on a daily or continuous basis for a long time to come.  With the desaturation you have reported under ONLY extreme exertional conditions, it may be sooner than you might think.  But, I would be surprised if it is any sooner than two years.  And even then, it would likely be only for sleep and exercise/exertion where you must get pretty vigorous/intense.

Best Regards,

Mark

COPD - General Information & Understanding

Hi Mark,

 

I have written to you a couple of times now about my mild COPD.  I am on Seretide 500 powder inhaler.  What type inhaler is this?  I was on a purple spray one last year.  Does it take a few weeks to get in your system?  I am breathing a lot better, now.  Was the shock of being told I have mild COPD (that) sent me a bit over the edge as I have never smoked.  Am blowing regular 450 on peak flow.  Am 56.  But, now I have started a treadmill, running about a mile and a half with ease.  Can this COPD ever get better, or am I doomed to go downhill?   Also, I have Herpes.  Been told this gives you flu-like symptoms. Can my spirometry test be wrong?  I hear someone got told they had COPD then went for a second opinion which said they never had asthma.  I also have been doing breathing exercises, breathing in ‘til I can’t breathe in no more, hold for a second, then breathe out with pursed lips and get every drop of air out my lungs.  I feel a bit light-headed at the very end of breathing out.  Is this normal?  Also, sometimes I sneeze when I do exercises, getting a bit of sputum up.  Is this sputum badness out of my lungs getting’ spat out good for your lungs?   Do you think there will ever be a cure for COPD or anything to stop it getting worse?   With better medication?  Also, I was getting over a chest infection when I had spirometry test.  I was diagnosed with asthma when I was 21.  I had a lot of chest infections.  Then I worked out all my life, Karate, weights.  I never have too much fatty stuff.  I eat fruit.  My doctor said don’t worry, we got it in time.  Is he just trying to make me feel better.  When you tell people they have emphysema, they say, oh that’s bad.  My nan died of that.  So, you can see my concern.  Thanks for your answers.  Paul

 

Hi Paul,

 

You continue to be very concerned about your possible lung disease, though you don’t seem to appreciate that if you can “run” on the treadmill, especially for a mile and a half, that you are in pretty darned good shape DESPITE your COPD.  Now you didn’t say if you ‘actually’ RUN.  So, if you are walking very slowly for that mile and a half, that is a different story.   If you are doing that mile and a half in less than 30 minutes, then you are walking briskly.  If you actually run, then you should be covering that mile and a half in about 10 minutes or less. 

 

Once one had COPD, the NEVER get rid of it.  If they take good care of themselves – and it sounds like you are doing just that AND doing it well – then they usually see very little progression of their disease even over many years in the future.  So, you should expect to stay in good shape and be able to do most anything you want to do for many years to come.  Just because a loved one died from COPD doesn’t mean that you will automatically do the same thing!  Many people have mild COPD for the last half of their life and die of OTHER causes, not from the COPD.  It seems like you should be able to expect to do the same!  So, I don’t think your doctor is just trying to make you feel better and is not telling you the truth.  He is right – you SHOULD b e fine for many years to come if you keep doing all the right things.

 

A cure for COPD is something we all dream about.   But, I suspect it is a long way in the future.  In the mean time, we need to work hard to prevent it and to treat it with the best tools we have until a cure is found.  In ANY case, I would urge you to stop worrying!  You should be in good shape for a long time to come!

 

Best Wishes,

 

Mark

 

Exercise Concerns, Longevity and Hope

Hi Mark,
   I am fairly new to site, I was using copd international. I should of been here sooner. I am a 51 yr old female with severe copd.I have been on 02 3 yrs.I despise the 02.It took a long time to accept it. I got off it once but back on. I purchased an oximeter from this site and love it. My 02 respiratory guy came over and when I walk without it it drops to 88.He also said my heart is 120 and above which scared me.I am going for another ekg.I quit smoking 1 yr ago and since have not been in hospital as I have been close to death 2 yrs ago when my 02 was low and carbon was high I eat healthy,veggies,fruit,grains,etc weigh 130 and bought treadmill but when exercising my pulse went to 146 and I go only 2 mins.I can not seem to walk far. I was hoping to increase my walking by spring and wondered if my chances of living till 60 or longer are slim. My life feels dreadful with this disease. I am going to pulmonary Feb.16 and I can not blow out good I think my fev1 was 17 I yr ago.  is there hope for me?
                               Regards, Sue

Hi Sue,

There's ALWAYS hope!  That is the one thing you should NOT give up on!  Have you been tested for Alpha-1-Antitrypsin-Deficiency Emphysema?  You are too young, comparatively speaking to have developed COPD so severe - even with a significant smoking history.  So you should ask your doctor to help you get tested.  I don't know about Canada, but, here in the USA, it is a "free" test!  And it is easy to do, in terms of collecting the necessary specimen.

When one has COPD severe enough to cause hypoxia AND they become significantly limited in their level of activity, they get "out of shape", though it might come on slowly and insidiously.  When they DO get up and move, beyond their oxygen dropping if not adequately supplemented, their heart rate will expectedly increase in the manner which you describe.  That, in itself, is not a problem  If you continue to exercise, despite the high heart rate, keeping your exercise "intensity" appropriately low enough not to invoke problematic consequences, yet high enough to allow for conditioning to occur, then you will see that over time, it will come down to much lower levels AND will not jump as high with increasingly more intense exercise.

If you are walking too fast on the treadmill or if you have it on ANY incline, it is not surprising that you play out so soon.  You should be sticking to a low speed that allows you to go up to 30 minutes, NON-STOP, before increasing the speed.  Then you should NOT add any grade until you can walk for at least 30 minutes at a speed of about 3 mph. That may take you months to achieve.

It is good that you are getting started in Pulmonary Rehab.  Hopefully that will set you on a better path of regaining conditioning and health.

I doubt the EKG will show anything that isn't already known.  But, you should be getting one annually, if not more often, anyway, as part of your routine health screening.  You didn't mention any inhaled medications you use.  Hopefully, you are on a combination of inhalers that fits your very low FEV1 (17 %).  At that low a level, you are in serious shape, but, again, NOT without hope to improve a LOT.  Is lung transplant something you would consider - or available as an option for you?

In the end, no one can say that you will or will not see 60.  There is much you can do that you are on track to get under way.  That and time will tell.  Work on living  - NOT on avoiding dying!

Best wishes,

Mark

January 22nd, 2012

Quitting Smoking & Will the Numbers Improve

Hello,

My FEV1/FEV (%) was 78 the last time I had a Spirometry Test --- I am on Champix and have quit smoking - my quit day was a few days ago - I am scheduled for another Spirometry Test in a couple of days .  Will my % improve from the 78? Am I in the "mild" range of COPD?

Thank you for your time in answering my questions.

Sandra

Hi Sandra,

Yes, you ARE in the "mild" range of COPD.  Congrats on quitting smoking!  Don't expect much change in your FEV1 - at least not this soon - if any change will be forthcoming.  At 78 % you are still very high in pulmonary mechanics and shouldn't have any significant symptoms from your COPD.  Over time, you should notice even better breathing.  Keep active!  Eat healthy! Get plenty of rest for your needs.  And you should be in great shape for a long time to come! 

Best Wishes,

Mark

What is Atrovent?

What is Atrovent  hfa Spray q i d  Wht is it for ?


Tom

Atrovent is one of the two primarily administered "bronchodilator" medications.  They relax your bronchial tubes and improve your ability to move air into and out from your lungs with less work.    It is from the class of medications called "anticholinergics". 

Atrovent is usually paired with another complimentary - but different-acting - bronchodilator from the "beta-agonist" class.  Each does what it does through a different mechanism or "pathway".  So, one is not necessarily a 'replacement' or 'substitute' for the other.  But, together they work better than each one can alone to produce an overall improvement in your breathing.  The most common beta agonist used/prescribed is 'albuterol'.  You may likely be prescribed BOTH medications to be taken close together for best effect.

Best Regards,

Mark

Low Iron, Tight Chest

Hi Mark;

 I wrote to you a  week ago about my mild copd.   This week my chest was a bit tight and I have been having panic attacks thinking about it. I  don't want to be on oxygen in a wheelchair;  cant stop thinking about it.  I  went to the hospital on Saturday  because my chest was tight,  had x-ray,  came up clear.   Had blood tests said my iron count was 9 and a bit should be 13 in a man.  I was diagnosed as a anemic last year my count was a 7;  felt terrible couldn't really work or do much with out getting tired.  I went on iron tablets in August and they worked;  felt good,  doc said come of them and I did but when I had a blood test in the hospital it was a 9 so I am losing iron.  Also I was  told I had a hiatus hernia. I  use to get heart burn;  don't get it much now but hospital said its probably my worrying about copd that's making my chest tight.  It's not too bad this week;  after x-ray was clear.  I got copd mild;  never smoked.  Can my working as a tree surgeon caused it with the pollen as I did have asthma when I started job.  Was in job for 20 year; s just want to breath easy.   Also I blow 450 to 500 on meter blower may b 400 when I get up when my chest is easy and clear I blow a 500 am 56 years old, always watched what I eat, and work out with weights. Could it b because my iron is low that I am chesty?

Paul

Hi Paul,

No one can tell you "why" you develop COPD when you are not a smoker.  Most likely, 'we believe' it is related to heredity and triggered by histories like you seem to have - your asthma and working with the trees, though they likely are not the source of a significant factor or problem any more than having had asthma for some years.  BUT, with the peak flows you report, you don't seem to have any 'clinically significant' affect from it - 500 ml being an excellent peak flow.    Even 400 is very good!  Asthmatics who have problems are down around 250 and less!

I'm thinking - as you seem to be - and as others seem to be telling you - that you have very mild disease.  It would be helpful to know what your FEV-1 is.  But, going out on a limb, I'd bet it is greater than 70 % of what would be predicted for you and your age. Folks can easily 'worry' themselves into symptoms like you report having.  I feel confident in telling you that your worst fears - being on oxygen and in a wheelchair-  are so far off into any possible future that you'd not be able to see them, even with a strong pair of binoculars! 

You should actually be most concerned about your iron deficiency and get that corrected.  It is of much more immediate concern than ANY concern you have about lung disease.    And it can do more to make you feel bad - AND contribute to any difficulty breathing and/or chest tightness you are feeling!  Realize that iron carries oxygen in our body.  If your body senses that it is not getting enough oxygen, it will signal to you to do more work to bring in more oxygen.  THAT more than any COPD you might have can be the cause of any breathing symptoms you now have, including the tight chest, though worry and panic can easily play a big part, too. 

Above all, keep foremost in your mind the fact that folks with half the lung function you have - who have MUCH MORE advanced lung disease/COPD than you now have or are likely to progress to in the next MANY years - are able to be VERY active, don't yet require oxygen and are far from needing a wheelchair.  You need to read more about the disease to learn where your fears can be misplaced.  Until folks' FV-1 drops to less than 30 % of what it should normally be - a LONG time off in your future - they don't have limitations that present significant difficulties in their lives.

If you live each day worrying about what is predictably many years - even decades - off in the future, you will miss so much of living and everything that is good in life.  Don't WASTE your life living like that!  You likely don't have enough lung disease to worry about what you are spending lots of time and emotion worrying about NOW.  You may likely NEVER reach a point where COPD becomes a primary ailment and limitation in your life.

As I said in an earlier response, STAY ACTIVE!  Eat well and get the rest you need - and QUIT WORRYING - and you'll live a long and happy life without problems with lung disease!  If you have a little bit of asthma along the way, keep it controlled and at bay and you shouldn't have any significant difficulties.

Best Wishes,

Mark

Can a Person Tell if They're Retaining CO2?

Assuming a person isn’t a usual retainer, Is there any way for a patient to know, or tell that they’re starting to retain CO2. (Not as an on-going issue but something that can crop up)   If there is a way to tell, is there anything a person can do to minimize or avert it?  Thanks

Scott 

Hi Scott,

The only way to know if you retain CO2 is to directly measure it.  That can be done with a device that measure the air you exhale.  It measures how much CO2 is in your exhaled gas at the END of your exhalation.  A blood gas is an "invasive" but the most accurate means to measure your CO2.  Not unless other clinical information suggests that you 'might' be at risk for CO2-retention, would we/I recommend getting one done. 

Folks rarely begin retaining CO2 before their FEV1 drops below 30 % of predicted.  Even then, many don't begin retaining until it drops progressively below 20 % of predicted.  If one develops pulmonary hypertension, their tendency to retain CO2 will be enhanced at the high FEV-1's, but, still most often below the 30 % line.

CO2-retention doesn't "crop up" as a usual and/or 'short-lived' problem.  In advanced COPD it is a response/result of the physical damage to the lungs that results in chronic hyperinflation, as we see it in advanced emphysema.  So, you are thinking off the mark if you think that you can develop it as a short-lived or passing ailment.  Once there, it is there for the duration.  There is NOTHING you can do to "avert it" or "prevent it" or "minimize it" or "make it go away", once it's there.

CO2 can "acutely" increase because of sudden respiratory compromise.  That is an emergency and it is obvious that those who experiences it are very ill and in trouble.  We call that occurrence "Acute Respiratory Failure" and jump on with rapid intervention to resolve it.  That is not something you should spend time worrying about as it is rare. 

Again, the only way to "know" that you retain CO2 is to measure it.  You should NOT worry if you might be entering the realm of chronic CO2-retention until and unless your lung disease is WELL-advanced and you are struggling to do simple daily activities.

Even when CO2-retention DOES occur, it is not a problem that needs resolution!  It is actually a 'positive' adjustment that the body makes to contend with the poor ventilation that goes with well-advanced COPD.  Once there, to try to make it go away or be less would actually mess up bodily functions rather than provide any positive effect or improvement.

Best Wishes,

Mark

 

 

January 15th, 2012

COPD or a Fungal Infection

My father came in contact with some serious fungus two years ago while helping a friend clean out the basement of a flooded cottage.  Doctors won't acknowledge or entertain the fact that it's a fungus in the lungs and sinuses they keep saying and treating him like he has asthma or COPD.  I have read many things and he has become his own doctor for approx.2 years now.  He has been in and out of hospitals half a dozen times due to not being able to breathe.  Doctors fill him up with Prednisone, Antibiotics and symbicort or Advair.  He had severe allergic reactions to symbicort and advair while in hospital so Doctors finally realized these two medications could not be used to assist him in his breathing.  The breathing difficulty subsides after approx.two weeks stay in the hospital because the prednisone and antibiotics are only suppressing the symptoms (which are asthma like) of the fungus.  I have read many forums and all the people discussing their symptoms are exactly like my Father...sinuses fill up with mucous, nose drips clear liquid, lungs fill up with mucous, when he is able to clear his lungs, it's clear, frothy mucous that's being expelled occasionally with little "fungus plug like substances".  He even went as far as purchasing his own monitor to track his oxygen level and heart rate.  This week, he is fighting for breath, oxygen level staying mid to low 80's up to 90 or 91.  He is petrified to go back to the hospital because they just want to fill him up with drugs to cover up the symptoms and get him home.  He has limited his diet extremely, no sugars, anti fungal products galore, he is doing everything possible as I said he has researched a lot and has become his own "doctor".  I am at a loss!  We don't know what to do...my Father has asked me to type up his Will and Power of Attorney to prepare for the worst.  My Father feels that if he had oxygen at home, he might be able to fight this fungus naturally, (oxygen gives him the strength to expel the mucous) but no Doctor will agree to prescribe oxygen

Cindy

Hi Cindy,

I'm sorry to read of your father's difficulties and frustrations.  But, my first impression is that he is on the wrong track with his insistence that he is suffering from a fungus.  While I can't say one way or another, from where I sit, that he "doesn't" suffer from a long-term fungal infection, I 'can' say that from a clinical standpoint that the likelihood is remote, at best.  Had it been a fungal infection, evidence more than what you have related - and much more meaningful - would long ago have become apparent.  Much of his problems can be argued to result from a combination of his rejection of appropriate treatment for his breathing difficulties and - perhaps even more so - from self-treatment with substances that can easily be worsening, if not outright causing his symptoms.

I am very curious to know what his "severer allergic reactions" were to Advair and Symbicort.  Can you describe them more specifically for me?

I am further suspicious of the potential for a fungus to be at fault since prednisone suppresses immunity such that fungi and other opportunistic pathogens have an "easier" time causing symptoms.  Were the prednisone simply temporarily suppressing any fungal influences, they should come back with a vengeance within 72 hours after his last dose at the hospital.  Then again, if he takes long-term/maintenance prednisone, his symptoms could (and should) be continually suppressed, so the notion of a fungal infection - especially lasting this long without being more readily detectable by now - is highly unlikely. 

The worst part of his situation is that by rejecting the assessment and interventions of the medical team he is entrusted to AND by self-medicating with all manner of anti-fungal supplements, he is fostering the more rapid worsening of his COPD.

If he is truly observing desaturation with his pulse oximeter, he should take it with him to the doctor and demonstrate his observations.  You don't say if he has had pulmonary functions tests or what any of his measurements might be.  So I have no 'objective' information upon which to determine where he is in his lung disease process.

Oxygen, or use of oxygen will lend "NO" 'specific' assistance to fighting a fungal infection - naturally or otherwise.  His thoughts on that are misplaced.  BUT, with the desaturation you describe, it suggests he is in an advanced state of his COPD and would definitely benefit both from a health and a functional standpoint, from the use of oxygen.  In most locations in Canada, the requirements for needing supplemental oxygen are the same as here in the US.  By those means, he seems to qualify without question.  So, push for it - and push HARD!

That is about all I can tell you at this point.  There is one other test that 'might' settle the question of the presence of fungus.  If he has not had his sputum 'cultured' for the presence of fungal organisms, that is a simple enough test to do and won't break the health care system bank.  If he has suspicious or inconclusive results, a bronchoscopy to obtain deeper-residing specimens can often provide the definitive answer.  You might ask his doctor about those two possibilities.  In any case, you simply CANNOT say that you are seeing "fungus plug-like substances" in expelled secretions.  Mucus plugs are mucus plugs, regardless of contents or origin.   There is nothing beyond specific colours or odors that can indicate the presence of one kind of bacteria or another.  And those colours and odors are VERY specific to each pathogen that produces or emits them.

I fear that his rejection of qualified medical assessment and opinions and insistence upon his problem being a fungal infection AND the rejection of interventions that can certainly provide significant benefit in favor of those his is concocting from his lay resources are both responsible for his rocky course (several exacerbations and admissions) over these past two years AND his inability to get satisfactory collaboration from his medical professionals.   At some point, they too become frustrated and take on an attitude of "What's the use? He won't listen to what we have to say or suggest."

Perhaps you all need to sit down together and sort out all the questions, suspicions and frustrations that are interfering with your ability to find effective relief and improvement in his condition.  Otherwise, I fear that sadly, you may be giving attention to his will sooner than is necessary.  Please step back and give thought to the possibility that he is wrong and that his medical team have a better idea of what is going on and what should be done.  But, also push for oxygen in the meantime, as I described.

Best Wishes,

Mark

How Bad is my COPD?

Hi  Mark;   I live in the uk am a very young 56 kept in shape all my life when I left school at 15 worked at a car components grinding the left over asbestos of the car brake shoe to glue a new one on no mask on was only in the job 1 week was not doing the grinding of shoes all day just now and again then in 1977 started work as a tree surgeon and developed a cold that lasted 4 a year had breathing problems was told I had asthma I have never smoked done this job 4   20 years then after that got finished up done a bit of car spraying on off as hobby was on ventolin inhalers then in sep this year had breathing teats done in my local hospital test said I have mild copd am very worried thinking am going to die soon I have been around smokers 4 years passive do u think the asbestos has caused this or passive  smoking I am on a powdered inhaler now they r very good keep my lungs easy to breath I can walk up 10 floors my legs do get bit tired round the 6 floor when I get to the tenth floor my lungs sort of burn will I get all the stages of copd then die at the last stage I feel ok on the inhalers my doc says I don't have asthma now but mild copd and not to worry


Paul

Hi Paul, 

I suspect that you are worrying way too much about the disease and your future, as well as a lot of things in your past that have little if anything to do with any COPD you might now have or the course you can expect it to take in many years of your future.  The simple fact that you can climb those many flights of stairs tells me that ANY lung disease you may 'now' have is not "clinically significant">  Your asbestos exposure was not enough to present concern for that type of lung disease.  Your other activities - including exposure to second hand smoke - are not significant enough to play a meaningful role in development of "problematic COPD" or other lung disease.

My bet is that you have a better chance of meeting your demise in any number of other accidental ways LONG before you'll succumb to lung disease.  Just keep active and as vigorous as you are now and I'll look forward to reading your posts to COPD-Canada 20, 30 and more years down the road - that is IF "I" can still read and pay attention! 

Best Wishes,

Mark

Follow Up From Last Week (January 8th Q's & A's)

First of all thank you so much for answering my previous questions.


I have since returned to the doctor for my 3rd visit. I have  quit smoking. I requested this visit (1 week earlier than planned) because I have been having headaches every morning, dizziness, continued chest pressure and all I want to do is sleep all the time.At this visit I was only seen by the P.A. not the doctor. She said my lungs sounded better. She stated she could not repeat the ABG's because insurance would not pay for it. I asked if my HbCO levels could cause any of my symptoms and she said usual not. She stated that I could see my PCP or a cardiologist for the chest pressure they didn't do EKG's. She wanted me to have a Sinus CT which I refused at this time. She continued all meds but added a Nocturnal Oximetry. I always wait over an hour to see the physician, he has never given me any education on pulmonary rehab and frankly seems annoyed when I ask him questions. I firmly believe in research and patient educating themselves on their disease. I have been in the medical field for over 25 years (until my illness) and I recognize when a physician is not "listening" to the patient. When I ask about other medical problems I am having to see if it relates to my lung disease he states I need to see a specialist (ex: gasto problems/gastoenterologist, heart/chest pressure problems/cardiologist, headaches, dizziness/neurologist) without explaining if any of these problems are/can be related to my COPD. Frankly, he looks at the numbers, tells me briefly what some of them mean, listens to my lungs & "see you in 4 weeks".
Is this typical COPD treatment? What about education, rehab? I feel like this is as good as it gets and they simply check the values, change/increase medications and make another appointment. On my 2nd visit with him he stated "you are being anxious". I was so calm and at peace with the diagnosis realizing I need to help myself and go on with life. I always leave his office feeling bad and as if he shows no concern for helping me as though my problems have little validity and he's too busy to give me proper care. I am a compliant patient. I try not to question his decisions.
I guess what I'm asking is what should on expect from their physician in the way of treatment for this disease? Or are my expectations too high?
I just feel so lost at this point.  Thank you for listening.

Susan

Hi Mark,
 Thanks for the good information. I have since returned to my doctor on 1.5.2012. He didn't see me the P.A. seen me. She said my lungs sounded better but couldn't repeat the ABG's due ti insurance wouldn't pay for it! She stated she didn't know why I was so sleepy all of the time, having morning headaches that maybe I needed to see a neurologist?? When I asked about the 8.2% side effects I had researched  that coincided with my problems, she stated it was not likely to cause any of them. No repeat CXY,ABG's just listened to my lungs and ordered a Sinus CT and Nocturnal Pulse Oximetry. I refused the CT for now but agreed to the pulse ox. They have never offered any rehab to me. When I asked about checking my heart they said IF they seen any problems they would refer me to a cardiologist ( I have MVP). When I ask about staging they tell me they don't stage Emphysema/COPD. When I question results they simply tell me it takes a long time for the meds to work and they will see me in 4 more weeks. I really feel like they don't listen to the patient. I always feel bad when I leave the office visit. I believe they are telling me this is as good as it gets.


Susan

Hi Susan,

I'm going to respond to this question and the one that follows since they were apparently duplicate posts from you, sent at different times, this one with more detailed information.

Your PA is correct that the HbgCO you reported should not be responsible for your complaints.  It's GREAT that you have quit smoking.  THAT should go far towards allowing your CO levels to return to normal for a non-smoker.  Have you considered that it is a frequent response for someone to experience symptoms of depression when quitting smoking?  One of the advantages of Welbutrin and Chantix are their anti-depressive action which helps combat the problem when quitting tobacco consumption.  Your complaints are suspicious for mild depression, though I can only offer that as a possibility and speculation from where I sit.

While it seems that your doctor wants only to address your pulmonary problems - and seems to be addressing them in a reasonable manner as best I can ascertain, perhaps you should see a cardiologist for an EKG, if you are concerned there might be a cardiac problem - and in view of your MVP problem.  It is possible you have reached a point in your life when you need a medication to assist in correction of difficulties that might be developing in relation to that problem.  It wouldn't hurt to rule it out, anyway, even if all it does is set your mind better at ease.

It is possible you are overly concerned about your condition at this point.  Yet, if there is something going on that needs attention, you would do well to learn that sooner than later, too.  Think about seeking further opinion from others.

Best Wishes, 

Mark

As COPD Progresses, is Oxygen Inevitable?

Hi Mark.

COPD is a very interesting disease as no two cases are exactly a like.

I was diagnosed in 2002, and I can honestly say that I am better now then in 2002. The proper exercise and meds have done it for me BUT the greatest factor has been my component of asthma. When Diagnosed I had an FEV1 of 25% of predicted. After a few puffs of Ventolin, My FEV 1 shot up to 46% of predicted which is a huge difference.
My Pulmo said that adult induced asthma in patients with COPD is usually attributed to having allergies as a child. He was right. I had severe Hay fever as a child.

My question Mark is this.

Currently I only need 02 when flying. On the ground I am fine almost all of the time. I sometimes desaturate with extreme physical activity, yet when on the treadmill
for 30 minutes I seem to be fine. I have taken my 02 levels on the treadmill and the numbers seem to bounce around from a low of 91-95. It is NEVER below 91.

Will all or most COPD patients Mark require 02 at some point in their disease, or have you seen some people go without requiring 02 for the life of their disease?

Here in Canada Mark in order just to get a prescription for 02 requires that your 02 levels must be consistently below 88. I was able to get a script for 02 for flying because I took a H.A.S.T.  Test.

As always, thanks for all your help, and my personal best to you and your family

Philip

Hi Philip,

While we have had the "no two cases are alike" discussion before - in which I have contended that while there may be individual quirks much of the time, the pattern and progression, as well as the symptoms and defects have MUCH in common among individuals, the notion of the condition "exactly alike" does not speak much to the issue as a whole.

The answer to your question about the inevitability of need for supplemental oxygen therapy is essentially: "Yes."  Most all folks whose COPD continues to advance to the more severe side of the disease end up requiring supplemental oxygen therapy.   You, yourself, might be in need of it down the line as evidenced by your mild, but nevertheless persistent decreases in oxygen.

All you can do is do your best to stay in the best shape and pay close attention to optimizing your lifestyle to keep progression on a slow pace.  Who knows, you might even succumb to something else - many years down the road - and long before you reach a point of needing LTOT.  That would be my hope for you, any way! 

Best wishes,

Mark

Lung Scarring

Hi , my husband was told my the specialist that he has some old scars in his lungs and if she were to write a diagnosis it would be pulmonary fibrosis. My husband is 33 years old... He was never exposed to anything and was never a smoker. He doesn't have any symptoms and has normal pulmonary function test. I am wondering if you can help.
He was told to be reviewed again in 6 months - which is in March. I am concerned and sometimes worried. Can the hospital admit him and do all necessary tests to diagnose efficiently and look at previous test results and give an opinion?

Dahlia

Hi Dahlia,

I would go out on a limb, based upon what you have told me, and say that your young hubby has nothing to worry about with regard to lung disease.  Folks are often found to have scarring in their lungs that plays no part in their health picture.  If he feels fine and has normal pulmonary function, then that should be all you need to know to feel confident that he is OK and has a bright future in terms of lung function.  You didn't say why or how the finding of the scarring came about.  So, I don't know if he was having problems that resulted in the test being done that found the scarring.  But, if it was an incidental finding, then he should chalk it up to just that - an incidental finding.  If his follow-up in 6 months finds nothing new or of concern, and he continues to be without symptoms of concern, then I would think that further interval follow-up should not require more than a look at him and maybe an x-ray every several years.

Best wishes, 

Mark

 

January 8th, 2012

Exercise (Treadmill)  Goal and Oxygen Question

Hi Mark.....This is my first time to ask a question so I should give some background.....I was diagnosed with COPD in 2000 and was able to do most hings in my life for quite a few years....in the past couple of years though my life has become more restricted.....I use Spiriva and Advair and also take  recently turned it up to 3l.....I now live in an area where there is no respiratory therapist  so have a question...  I walk on the treadmill at a pace of 2mph for 30 minutes a day....usually....I find if the air pressure is low I struggle to do 20 or 25 minutes.....I am wondering if I should strive to go further faster and what should my goal be?  I should add that I am 71 years old.....please let me know if you have ideas.. Thank you! and Happy New year!!

Heather

Hi Heather,

You are doing well and on the right track to maximize what lung function you retain.  Indeed, you should strive to go further faster.  If 30 minutes is going to be your choice of maximum duration, you should work to increase toward 3 - 3.5 mph.  Ad 'interval' walking at some point, wherein you jump the speed be 0.5 - 0.7 mph - abruptly - and maintain the increased speed until you become as winded as you can stand.  sustain that windedness for a minute or two at which point you will drop the speed - again, abruptly - back to the lower level to 'recover' while continuing to walk - RATHER THAN stopping, altogether to rest.  You may have to drop your lower speed in order to maximize the approach.  So, say, for instance, you start at 2.0 mph and jump to 2.7 for your fast interval.  The  drop back to 2.0 for recovery.  It will seem slower when you drop back down to it - a good thing, as you want to keep moving while allowing yourself to regain more comfortable breathing.  As you do that more and more, you will see your fast interval increase.  When you get to where your fast interval is 20 of the 30 minutes (approximately) increase both speeds and work to increase the fast interval.  Over time (perhaps as much as a couple of months, you will see your overall speed increase to where maybe, 2.8 is your low speed, while 3.5 is your fast speed.  At that point, you can maintain those speed differences and add o1 or 2 % grade for the fast intervals, dropping the grade back to 0 for the recovery periods.

The most important factor in the mix will be to maintain the best oxygenation you can during your walking exercise.  You say you now use 3 L.  You may find you need 5 liters for exercise and to stay above 90 % saturation.  Be sure you have enough oxygen to supply your needs AND monitor your oxygen saturation with a personal oximeter.  If you don't currently have one, you can get a good one for $100 or a bit less.  Check out the Nonin line of oximeters  Look them up on-line)  (I have no financial interest in Nonin.  I just think it's about the best available.)

Let us know how you do over time.   Best Wishes,                 Mark

(Note:  You can also purchase a finger pulse oximeter from FaCT Canada in British Columbia starting at  $59.95 if you're a COPD Canada Patient Network Member.  This also includes the carrying case and free shipping  Finger Pulse Oximeters)

Lung Volume Increase Question(s)

Hi Mark, I had childhood allergies and Asthma. Nothing really significant that I didn't live with. I worked a as a Firefighter of 30 years and retired 2 and 1/2 years ago. One of the reasons I retired is because I couldn't t do the physical demands anymore. my breathing was getting worse and I had a few scary moments. I took in a lot of smoke over the years. I never smoked cigarettes. I see a Pulmonologists every 6months. My AM regimen is Spiriva, Advair, 1 81 mg aspirin, and 1 , 10 mg Loretadine, with about 16 ounces of water. I'm on 2 lpm of oxygen at night time for sleep hypoxia. Obviously I have COPD. my blood work has been good. I stay active as I can. Sometimes I have to work every breath to keep breathing. I use albuterol 2 or 3 x's a month as needed. I use a nebulizer every few months or so as needed. My PFT says I have the lungs of an 80 year old. OH yea, I'm 58 years old. I use a Netty pot every am with a baking soda and canning salt solution to cleanse my sinuses. I gat a bad cold and or flu every year at least a couple of times that require antibiotics. My PFT 2'xs ago showed that I lost 700 cc's of lung volume, however through hard work, and following my orders I gained back 200 cc's of volume. My question is there anything I' missing? Can I increase my lung volume through any specific exercises . How about breathing exercises. Are there any food supplements or herbs that are recommended?                  Thank You Bill

 

Hi Bill,

There is nothing you can do to increase your lung volumes, per se.  They will fluctuate up and down in accordance with your exacerbations (colds, bronchitis events, etc).  Walking exercise is very good to maintain your best pulmonary function within the limitations you now have.  You are a tough guy as exemplified by the difficulty breathing that your report during activity.  While it's not fun or comfortable to sustain hard breathing work, if is a MUST to survive and thrive. AND, breathing hard, while it may 'seem' like it will 'do you in' is not a bad thing and WON'T hurt you AS LONG AS your oxygen saturation is > or = 90 % during those periods of activity.  So, if you don't have an oximeter, it would be a great idea to purchase one.  I have recommended Nonin as a source for a choice of several that are very good.  See my response to Heather for more information.

Staying on top of your condition - with attention to exacerbations as soon as possible is a must for continued good management of your disease.  You are a young guy, at 58, to have such severe COPD.  But, with your fire-fighter history, it unfortunately, is no great surprise.  It is sad that you suffer these consequences for your many years of saving lives and property.  I hope your community is appropriately appreciative and supportive of your sacrifice!

Many folks are finding additional benefit from adding NAC (N-Acetyl Cysteine) to their medication regimen.  It has anti-inflammatory and mucus thinning benefit.  It can be purchased over the counter and should be taken 1200 mg once a day, up to 2400 mg (1200 mg, twice a day) during bouts of bronchitis and colds)  Taks an addition 1000 - 2000 mg of vitamin C with the NAC which helps thwart the formation of kidney stones in some folks who take NAC (very rare occurrence/complication).

Other than those suggestions, the key to survival and staying in the best shape possible is to KEEP MOVING!  Exercise is of critical importance.  With that, adequate oxygenations a must to prevent damage to your heart over time.  You now use oxygen at night for sleep hypoxia.  I would wager that if you desaturate during sleep, you also desaturate with exertion.  And it may not take much exertion to produce dangerous drops in your oxygen level.  So, be sure to check out that factor as soon as possible so you can address and correct it as soon as possible, too.

Best Wishes,

Mark

Breathing Test Explanations & COPD Understanding  (2 parts)

I was diagnosed with severe COPD/Emphysema in October  of this year. On my 1st pulmonary doctor visit on December 8th, 2011, my ABG's were :pH 7.49, PCO2 36.0, PO2 79.0, HCO3 27.2, BE 4.2, Hb 13.7, SaO2 97.5, HbCO 6.9. FIO2 21.00.

 I was diagnosed with Acute Pleurisy & Chronic Bronchitis, Dyspnea, COPD w/ALE (don't know what ALE means), COPD severe,  Emphysema, nicotine addiction, cigarette abuse. The physician stated that I was to return on the following Monday (5 days later) & if HbCO values remained the same he would admit me to the hospital. He started me on Bactrin DS BID, Prednisone 40 mg 4 x day, Tessalone Pearls PRN, Musinex BID, hold Advair and use DuoNebs QID, continue with Xanax and Trazadone..


When I returned on Monday 12/12/2011, he stated my HbCO was now 8.2% (didn't tell me the other values) but stated he wasn't as concerned with the 8.2 % now because of the fluctuation in the other values. He had me do the "timed walking test" which was ok. He discontinued my DuoNebs, continue Prenisone Titration for 4 weeks, added Advair daily & use Ventolin Inhaler PRN severe SOB. He made my return appointment for 4 weeks later ( 01/09/2012).


I have done a lot of research online concerning COPD/Emphysema and PFT's/ABG's. Everything I have read indicates that the HbCO level of 8.2 is dangerously high and can be life-threatening.
My question is should I be concerned about the 8.2% level? The doctor didn't seem alarmed at this high value. Since the last visit I have become more lethargic, have slight memory problems, frequent angry outbursts and increased urinary/bowel incontinence (especially when coughing hard).
Maybe I need a second opinion?
Thank you for your time.

Susan

Hi Mark,
I recently sent you a question concerning my ABG's (AT 8.2). But, I forgot to include my PFT report:
SPIROMETRY:

FVC              59%
FEV1            38%
FEV1/FVC   53 POST
PEF               35
FEF 25-75    19
FIVC               47
FIF50%           0.97 POST
MVV                32 POST

LUNG VOLUMES:

VC          52
TLC         77
FRC PL   101
RV            123
RV/TLC    57
ERV          059
IC               1.06

AIRWAY RESISTANCE:

RAX          290%
GAW         38

DIFFUSION:

DLCO          33%
DL ADJ        33%
DLCO/AV     92

Susan

Answer to part 1 -

Susan, I hope you have quit smoking.  The CO will remain elevated in folks who continue to smoke.  The only other cause of chronically elevated CO is exposure to heavy traffic, as in the city where lots of care exhaust is breathed in, or in jobs where CO is infused into the air from combustion or other chemical reactions that emit CO.

Your blood gas actually shows modest "hyperventilation", often seen with various lung disease conditions and in response to low oxygen.  But, your oxygen level isn't significantly decreased to explain why that phenomenon is occurring in you.  Yet, if you are continuing to smoke, it could be from your body's response to the elevated CO.  In any case, the 8.2 CO and the question of continued tobacco use remain a question for me as you didn't include that in your information.

I don't know what the ALE means, either, unless it's your doctor's abbreviation for "Acute Lung Exacerbation".  Ask him what it means.

I don't think your necessarily need a second opinion.  You need to know from your doctor what you should be doing to reduce your symptoms and improve your health and function within the limitations you cannot change.  If you are not confident with your current doctor's care or skills, that would be an indication to seek a second opinion.  But, you didn't allude to any concerns of that type.  So, it is up to you to decide.  Even then, you need to have a specific objective in seeking another assessment and opinion.  If you don't fully know what your current doctor wants you to do, then another doctor won't be in any better position to second guess the first one.

Part 2 answer -

Your PFT's show a combination of obstructive (COPD) and possibly restrictive elements to your lung disease. Your ability to diffuse oxygen is reduced at 33 % which, when combined with the elevated CO adds up to explain your low paCO2 on your blood gas.  It doesn't help much with advising you on what to do.  Again, the question still hangs about the tobacco use and the cause for the 8.2 CO level.  Answer that and we may have better direction to go in terms of advice.

Best Wishes, Mark

 

 

Archived (Alphabetically Arranged) Questions and Answers for 2010, Mark Mangus,  BSRC, RRT, RPFT, FAARC

Archived (Alphabetically Arranged) Questions & Answers for 2011, Mark Mangus, BSRC, RRT, RPFT, FAARC

Archived (Alphabetically arranged) Questions and answers from 2008 and 2009, Tracy Cushing RRT

Do YOU have a Question for Mark

 

Site Map

Home

About Us

 

About Us: Who We Are & What We Believe

 

Full Contact Listing

 

Disclaimer & Policies

Membership

 

 

Why You Should Become a Member

 

Sign Up Form (on line)

 

Form (pdf) for Printing off & Mailing

 

Update Your Membership Info

$avings

 

 

 

Current Discounts for Members

Across Canada(COPD)

Pulmonary Rehab Facilities

Your Provincial Report Card

Provincial Health Ministers

Form Letters You Can Use

Letter Writing Campaign Results

Socialized Medicine

 

It's Tax

Deductible

Message Board/Forums

COPD in Canada Message Board/Forum open to the public-for patients - exchange info with your peers

Newsletters

 

 

2012

Spring

 

2011

Spring

Summer  Fall/Winter

 

2010

Spring 

Summer

Fall     Winter (Dec)

 

2009

Spring,   Summer, Fall   Winter

 

2008

Spring,   Summer, Fall   Winter

Pamphlets for Printing or Requesting (Free)

 

 

It Could Be COPD

 

What Can I Do?

Useful Links

 

COPD in Canada Message Board Forum

( open to the Public)

 

Useful Resource Links

General Info

 

 

Disclaimer & Policies

 

References

/Bibliography

 

Report Broken Links

 

General Inquiries

HOME

We comply with the

HONCodThis website is certified by Health On the Net Foundation. Click to verify.e standard for trustworthy health information.